Former WH flack Scott McClellan has a new book coming out wherein he reveals that people in the Bush Administration had him fronting out lies to the public about the WH leak of Valerie Plame Wilson's CIA ties. Color me shocked. From E&P:
.."The most powerful leader in the world had called upon me to speak on his behalf and help restore credibility he lost amid the failure to find weapons of mass destruction in Iraq. So I stood at the White house briefing room podium in front of the glare of the klieg lights for the better part of two weeks and publicly exonerated two of the senior-most aides in the White House: Karl Rove and Scooter Libby.
"There was one problem. It was not true.
"I had unknowingly passed along false information. And five of the highest ranking officials in the administration were involved in my doing so: Rove, Libby, the vice President, the President's chief of staff, and the president himself."
Do tell, Scott. How, exectly, were "Rove, Libby, the vice President, the President's chief of staff, and the president himself" involved in your lying to the public? I'd like all the details, please. Including when you learned that these were lies and what you did to correct the public misperceptions, if anything, what sorts of discussions were had about this in the WH, and whether you questioned the information when it was first given to you -- or just obligingly parroted as you were told unless and until you were confronted with the fact that you were telling lies. And I'm certain I'm not alone in that sentiment. For your sake, I do hope you were fully forthcoming about this with the FBI. I'm just saying.
I think Kevin Drum summed this mini-kerfuffle up nicely:
Now, Lord knows I don't want to question McClellan's claim that his book was "written with no agenda other than to record his experiences and insights for the benefit of history." But would it be presumptuous of me to suspect that his explanation of Plamegate is somehow going to make it out as nothing more than a silly mistake that the press blew all out of proportion?
Nothing like a little game of pass the buck between the smarm merchants of Bushworld, is there? Note the utter failure to take responsibility for lying to the public, the shunting of said responsibility onto others who have also failed to take responsibility for their respective actions, and the working of "the President's chief of staff" into the mix of players. Anyone want to place a bet as to whether Andy Card gets set up as the go to fall guy? Emptywheel caught the same Card reference, and mentions the Wells' card and notes that "just as a reminder, Card and Scottie left the White House within a week of each other--both happening just before Turdblossom's final grand jury appearance." (Anyone else's spidey sense getting a little tingle? And while we're asking questions, will Scottie own up to being one of the sources for the NYDailyNews story on Rove's bush league handling of the whole mess? Enquiring minds and all.)
Perhaps, Scottie will spill all the assorted beans to get even for the Bush Administration treating his momma so shabbily in her TX gubernatorial bid. Not bloody likely...but stranger things have happened in gooberville.
(Illustration entitled Free Manure By Mr. Fish via Commandante Agi.)
Login Here
Share This
Spotlight
I’m SHOCKED!
truth justice and uh…..
zed??
Spill it all, Scottie. Redeem yourself a little, and maybe you can move out a circle or two in the afterlife.
well not quite…lol
Eight years of President Clinton. Followed by eight more years of a Democratic president. GOP: your going to “take and like it”.
free manure… heh
great graphic, Mr. Fish…
Message to Republicans: You’re going to lose big time soon. And we’re coming after ALL the GOP law breakers.
EPU’d from last thread:
Biodun @ 73
sorry OT :)
CU study: Lead levels even well below U.S. standard may cause brain damage in children
By Susan Lang
Even very small amounts of lead in children’s blood — amounts well below the current federal standard — are associated with reduced IQ scores, finds a new, six-year Cornell study.
http://www.news.cornell.edu/st.....ge.sl.html
perhaps he is trying to avoid a subpoena of some kind?
That’s nice, Scotty. Thanks for sharing.
Now, where is the accountability?
Don’t these tell-all books fall into the category of knowing pornography when you see it?
So, do you think Scotty will tell all about his grand jury testimony? (Nah.)
Scott, why now?
Did it really take a publisher to say something closer to the truth?
Why didn’t you talk when you found out you had lied “unknowingly”.
Ah, that WH press corps:
Ask questions! Do your job!
so christy, can’t and shouldn’t fitzgerald get a new deposition from scott?
wouldn’t we assume fitz had questioned scott and wouldn’t we assume this is new information?
I am pretty sure everyone would be happy to grant scotty immunity for some clarity here
“I had unknowingly passed along false information. And five of the highest ranking officials in the administration were involved in my doing so: Rove, Libby, the vice President, the President’s chief of staff, and the president himself.”
Ummm….sounds like a conspiracy to me….
Fitz???!!!
So, is impeachment back on the table, Nancy? Helloooooo
perris at 18 — You are assuming Scott didn’t already spill all those beans in his grand jury testimony. And I’d say that is likely a false assumption.
On October 7th, 2003, President Bush famously declared of the outing of covert CIA operative Valerie Plame, “I don’t know if we’re going to find out the senior administration official.” Now we have more insight as to Bush’s misplaced confidence that the truth would remain hidden. In his new tell-all book, former White House press secretary Scott McClellan claims President Bush himself played an instrumental role in the failed cover up.
For the details, see:
“McClellan Book Confirms Bush’s October 2003 Plamegate Lie.”
This sounds like classic “tell all” marketing strategy…The publishers insist on one provacative sentence in an otherwise dull and fawning book which they use to promote sales. Buyer Beware. I recently bought “Dead Certain” that was marketed using such a passage- it turned out to be a total asskiss of the idiot president in every page other than the one the marketing quote came from.
perris @ 18
Has Scott decided to present the “new development” that coud re-kindle the investigation?
Nah, my wishes never come true.
I want them all. All Republican law breakers. Do you hear me Karl?
Man, I was so epu’d :-P Ha.
Wanted to know if I could copy the pic of Abu protesting student to spread the joy around a little? I agree, I think it will become iconic, and I wanna help with that :-P
Supremes will take up DC handgun law.
1,664 DAYZ AND THE KILLIN’ GOEZ ON AND ON AND..
Citizen Hardin Smith and the Firepup Freedom Fighters:
Sister Smith, please tell us what is possible legalwise with regard to Fitz-grand jury-Congress now with this stuff comin’ out. How does Fitz get back inta play and when ken he do it? Does this effect the Wilsons’ ability to get their suit reinstated? Do you still have confidence in Fitz’s honor and integrity to push the envelope ta get these bastards once and for all?
KEEP THE FAITH AND LET’S SEE A LITTLE OF THIS “RULE OF LAW” ALL YOU FOLKS HAVE BEEN TRUMPETING!!!
You are far, far kinder to the lying bastard than I will ever be.
As far as I’m concerned, he should have his picture put right next to Benedict Arnold.
He had the opportunity to stop this criminal cabal in its tracks and failed the courage test miserably.
No amount of lame Mea Culpa at this point is going to cut it.
He knew then, I can still see his face when he denied Roves actions to the American public on national television.
This guy is not getting a pass from me.
As I wrote earlier today,
Go lie down with the dogs you have chosen as your master.
May their fleas and feces fill your nose forever.
Thanks Christy, I dugg it.
(Digged? Dunno…)
If children are going to grow up in Bushworld- they’re better off with brain damage.
jackie @ 11
That’s just lovely, especially coming on the heels of a local news report last night that shows almost all of the xmas lighting available to purchase this year contains lead, so much so the packages now carry lead warnings.
You can expose yourself just by handling the wiring!
Amazing.
I dug it… but
digged will work as well, as a variant…
Norske at 27 — LHP has laid out the means by which Congress could shoehorn some of the info from Fitz. They just haven’t done the proper subpoenas as yet. But I’ve planted that information in a number of hands, nonetheless, and I hope that one day it gets put to proper use.
The problem is that with the Bush Administration there are multiple fires to be put out at once, and often the ones that I hope will get hit aren’t always the ones selected…
Now is the time to pressure the GOP.
SNOTTY SCOTTY…………….no shit, he’s a fucking liar. We don’t need a stinkin’ book from this fat, asshat to know that.
What a fucking whore……….didn’t save any money from your last job, asswipe???
TexBetsy @ 12
I don’t think so. I think Scotty is clean, and he knows it. His job was to go spout off the crap that Bush and Cheney (and Card and Rove and Libby) told him. It was not his job to verify the accuracy of said crap. That was Bush et al’s job, and it was the media’s job to double check it. He may be pond scum for taking (and doing) that job in the first place, but I don’t see how he can be held criminally liable for it if he wasn’t absolutely aware of the fact that he was spouting bullshit.
Christy Hardin Smith @ 21
but the scenario you are talking about is very disturbing Christ
I am surely disturbed that nothing could be done with this kind of information, though I understand the difficulty prosecuting the executive it is disturbing never the less
STTP in Ohio @ 31
Whoa!
Around here, signs start to go up where people offer their services in stringing up your xmas lights for you. I wonder how badly affected they are by this.
Would latex and/or garden gloves be enough to protect you?
digged will work, as an archaic variant…
I don’t think it’s a crime to lie to the press- if it were, congress and the White House would both be empty.
Shorter Scotty: Lies were made.
Dig, Dag, Dug?
Biodun @ 39
You can get away with darned near anything if you claim archaic variant *g*
…y’know, it’s probably just me, but for some reason this reeks of Rove. a little misdirect, even one that apparently indicts him, becomes the discernable reality that gets judiciously studied as, just down the hall, far smellier stuff is going on.
(and here, I should probably insert a chorus of Teresa Nielsen Hayden’s “I deeply resent the way this administration makes me feel like a nutbar conspiracy theorist”.)
rwcole @ 41
that’s not the crime, the crime would be what the president and the vice president did
scott looks like he’s willing to spill his guts, more then when he worked for the administration
I think we need to explore that possibility, scott can willingly divulge information fitz might have gathered but was not at liberty to make public
Anyone know if Sealed v Sealed is still sealed? I have to say that I was a bit surprised that Gonzo resigned when he did, and I keep wondering if that might be why. Rove left at about the same time, too. Probably just a coincidence, but I keep waiting for that thing to be unsealed.
OT, but related to a country deeply aligned with shrub:
http://abcnews.go.com/US/wireStory?id=3891433
“Justice?” from an ally. i’m sick about the sacrifices made under the guise of friendly foreign policy.
Cleanup in aisle 36?
Front page story in local gooper rag shows people in Baghdad having a peaceful lunch outside in the city–the surge is WORKING!!!
My political party might want to consider campaigning on the issue of ‘cleaning up government’. And more importantly, doing just that.
Now I’m really beginning to believe that Chimpy will have only Barney as friend when he leaves the WH permanently in January 2009. What are the chances
his wifeCondi wouldn’t dump (on) him at some point in the future? She’s planning to write a book, after all.1,664 DAYZ AND THE KILLIN’ GOEZ ON AND ON AND..
Firepup Freedom Fighters:
If Scotty’s mea culpa is an indicator that the bit players are beginnin’ ta sweat, they must have some reason ta believe that serious legal shit is comin’ down the track and they wanna get offa the rails. Notice that the folks with the most culpability aren’t makin’ a sound about this matter (includin’Karl Rove)…if Scotty’s self servin’ sniveling gets the Wilsons’ suit reinstated I’m willin’ ta go and buy the fuckin’ book!
KEEP THE FAITH AND PASS THE AMMUNITION, THE LITTLE RATS ARE GRABBIN’ THEIR LIFEJACKETS!!
Frank Probst @ 47
I remember it was rumored hands were being force and cheney was next
that never happened…dismay for me that it didn’t but here we are
were that the manure were free. it cost us dearly. we traded it for our rights as citizens, probably traded it for our country. since low grade manure is still the main component of our food chain, we are eating the excremental sandwich (with a little spritz of oil to change the taste) today and wondering why it resembles nothing an American has had to eat for quite a long time.
can we live without our tea?
NorskeFlamethrower @ 53
be still my weary heart
Biodun @ 40
Diggy Diggy Lo (YouTube)
rwcole @ 50
You haven’t seen the front page of the NYT yet, have you?
Wedding in Baghdad, ‘proving’ how much more peaceful and safe it is now.
Norske
Naw- it just means that Scotty wants to sell his fuckin book. He quit to make a little money while the iron was hot- and this is is last gasp attempt to cash in. Trust me- the book will not accuse Clusterfuck of anything prosecutable.
rw at 59 — They never do. The one hope is that the momma’s boy that he is was seriously pissed at Rove for screwing his momma over in TX. Payback on that score could be interesting…but unlikely, given that it’s Scotty and not his momma writing the book. (She’s got a loose cannon mouth habit and some serious balls when it comes to payback, I hear.)
And the motive for the conspiracy…
“The most powerful leader in the world had called upon me to speak on his behalf and help restore credibility he lost amid the failure to find weapons of mass destruction in Iraq.”
Here he’s saying that Bush personally asked him to save his butt, because his credibility was lost, “amid” the failure to find the WMDs, not “because of”…
The only way his credibility was “lost” was because of Wilson’s exposure of the lies about using false evidence leading us to war.
NorskeFlamethrower @ 53
Norske darlin’ I hate to burst your bubble, but I think te more likely scenario was Scotty left the WH cause he couldn’t stand the stink anymore–I think he sees himself as a decent honorable guy.
But he kept his mouth shut naively beliveing htat Bushco would take care of Scott’s mama.
They didn’t and then it took some time to find an agent and a ghost writer get the book aritten then the marketing people held it for the Christmas book buying rush season.
Hence the timing. There may be some stuff in this book that did not come out in the GJ if Pat did not realize to ask a particular question or a particular line of questions, but that is unlikely considering how thorough his investigation appears to have been.
Great post Christy!
That demonic Andy Card was also at Ashcroft’s bedside with his saddle shoe next to the respirator plug. The devious bastard had Abu G, Shrubby, Shooter, MC Rove, Rummy and Wimpy by the pendejos the entire time, and we were too stupid to figure it out.
Now he’s going to take over America by becoming a voting board member of Union Pacific? Stop that train!!
There is more than enough to impeach and convict these thugs. Any trial would uncover all and probably more lying and criminality than we already know.
It ain’t gonna happen.
But why are these uber criminals getting a pass?
Who is stopping this? The people are on board.
Cui Bono?
rwcole @ 50
Damien Cave had a similar piece up at the NYT. Life is returning to normal, except that he mentions in passing the millions who have left the country and/or been ethnically cleansed.
http://www.nytimes.com/2007/11.....ge.html?hp
It’s all rather discordant. OTOH Cave concentrates on one family that is marginally and perhaps temporarily better off but all the more general indicators remain negative. So things are getting better in Iraq except that they aren’t.
Sounds like Scotty needs a nice big fat glass of Fitzgerald.
ccmask @ 67
then what? trial and pardon?
P J Evans @ 58
Great news! Does that mean we can go home now?
1,664 DAYZ AND THE KILLIN’ GOEZ ON AND ON AND..
Citizen rwcole and the Firepup Freedom Fighters:
“Trust me - the book will not accuse Clusterfuck of anything prosecutable.”
I agree but that’s not the point,is it, the question is: can it give Fitz and the Congress an entry to reopen a dormant investigation (grand jury) and the Wilsons grounds to reinstate their suit?
KEEP THE FAITH AND DON’T LET THE BASTARDS OFF THE FUCKIN’ HOOK THIS TIME!!
Redd
Yeah- I’ve heard her talk—she’s a number three in the book of Texas stock characters “Woman with mouth as big as all outdoors”.
Bush pardoned two turkeys today. Rove and who else?
The Plame-CIA bit was not the only lie that Scott told that day at the WH press briefing. Here’s another lie (actually a number of lies):
Clusterfuck’s current stratergy is to convince the country that his surge is workin and that we’re winning in Iraq- leading to a gooper victory in a year.
As usual–the media are fallin all over one another to be first in line to kiss Clusterfuck’s smelly asshole.
biodun —- why don’t i feel protected?
It’s too bad “tell-all” books aren’t written under oath.
rwcole…EW. EW!!
George Orwell;
quite a quote which I just gleamed from think progress isn’t that?
anyway, check this out also from think progress
looks like they are setting us up for some kind of “catasthrophy” so they can make some kind of claim if the elections don’t look like they are going to be able to get fixed
It’s amazing that we are so gullible as to buy these piece of shit books- they never deliver.
Frank Probst @ 47
It will be unsealed when Richard Nixon
is exhumed….
rwcole @ 74
Sadly, Hillary Clinton was the first in line:
http://www.nypost.com/seven/08.....ate__h.htm
anna
Not nearly as disgusting as what the media are ACTUALLY doing in helping to create “the surge is working” narrative.
He’s saying they told him what lies to tell about the Plame case - not the WMD’s. He’s blatantly accusing them of conspiring to lie about the investigation they were all involved in.
This should be huge.
Unfingbelievable.
Fitz!!
rwcole–agreed. just a particularly pungent image, there…
And I really like this pithy bit from the book excerpt:
You can say that about most things (99.5 percent perhaps) that’s come out of the mouths of folks in BushCo.
Frank Probst @ 47
My fantasy about sealed vs sealed is that Fitz will unseal it on January 21, 2009. Right after Bush cannot pardon whomever is indicted. I fear this is just a fantasy, tho.
Christy Hardin Smith @ 21
What’s your theory, Christy? There still wasn’t enough evidence regarding intent?
Scotty just tryin to explain how he happened to stand up and and say that Rover had nothin to do with leaking Plame’s identity when in fact he had. Nothin new here except that Bush himself vouched for Rove- but seems to me he did that publicly anyway.
No comment
;>)
Helen @ 86
Bush will sign so many blanket pardons prior to that date that his hand will cramp. Finally, there will be some hard work from the little guy.
New Froomkin up Giving Thanks Inside the Bubble
When the GOP is the party of the “True Christians” why is anything a surprise. The following is some of the more revolting fundie swill that I have read.
From the Baptist Press:
Their prayer: that faith in Christ follows cyclone
DHAKA, Bangladesh (BP)–In the hours before Cyclone Sidr reached the coastal areas of Bangladesh, Southern Baptists and other Christians began praying -– aware that the Category 4 storm potentially could usher hundreds of thousands into an eternity without Jesus.
“Our prayer before the storm hit was that God would have mercy on the people of the country,” said Susan Galvin*, who serves among Bangladesh’s tribal people groups. “The note I sent to prayer partners was to pray for the millions who live in bamboo and tin homes.
(snip)
“Last night a lot of people died and entered an eternity of suffering,” Neely said. “Almost none of them has heard a Christian testimony or biblical explanation of who Christ really is. They have never heard the truth about who God really is, who they are in His sight or what God’s plan is to save us from our sin through Christ.
“Our hearts are heavy for all those without hope,” he said. “We are even more motivated now to go and tell them about the hope that is within us,” and to Southern Baptists he added, “We are so thankful for your continued prayers and support.”
(snip)
link
pma at 87 — Same theory I’ve been working under from the beginning: the nexus stops at Cheney’s door, and without Libby’s cooperation, getting to Cheney’s intent (because he’s smart enough to have used Libby as his message delivery system, thereby insulating himself from liability unless good soldier Libby spilled…which was always unlikely) is next to impossible.
There is no metaphore or simile that I can imagine that is adequate to capture the depth of the cesspool that is the Bush administration. He has outdone the poet’s ability to reflect.
1,664 DAYZ AND THE KILLIN’ GOEZ ON AND ON AND..
Citizen looseheadprop and the Firepup Freedom Fighters:
“Norske darlin’, I hate to burst your bubble but…that is unlikely considering how thorough his (Fitz’s) investigation seems to have been.”
Don’t worry about the Norske’s bubbles, they’re a lot stronger than Norwegian coffee but what about Fitz’s honor and integrity (not to mention his ego and sense of competition) do ya still trust ‘im ta push the envelope to get these bastards if he has the chance?
KEEP THE FAITH AND PASS THE AMMUNITION…JESUS, WE’VE BEEN CHEWIN’ THIS BONE A LONG TIME!!
Christy Hardin Smith @ 93
Excellent summary.
Expect McClellan to be swift-boated, swiftly. It will turn out that a) if he lied, he did it on his own. b) he lied other times, including one time in particular (that has yet to be found in his past speeches) and c) he’s full of sour grapes and is just trying to make money selling his book.
Badwater @ 90
Small editorial adjustment
Here’s Scott at a WH press briefing on October 25, 2005 repeating the same lie that he told at a WH press briefing on October 10, 2003 (what’s up with Octobers for lies at WH press briefings?):
Hugh @ 98
Nice addition!
Come back from lunch and get a fitzpost from Christy?
Wow, seems like the olden days.
LS @ 19
Fitz has personally mentioned a conspiracy before, but he did not charge it that way. Some element in the conspiracy must have been lacking, like proof of malicious intent, proof of prior knowledge that she was a covert agent, something did not fit the bill or Fitz would have charged it. Either that or you would have to concede that Fitz is sandbagging. Same thing goes for not charging Armitage. Take your pick, but I think the likelihood that he will charge now what he didn’t charge before is little to none.
Biodun @ 99
Not to mention Janurays, Februarys, Marches, etc.
George Simian @ 97
To quote Roy Scheider in Jaws “
We’reThey’re gonna need a bigger boat.”JF @ 103
tee hee
If I’m not mistaken, I believe the president issued an executive order saying that members of the executive branch were exempt from all investigations and prosecutions pertaining to anything they do. Oh, and executive priviledge extends to Scotty seeing that he once saw the president in a motorcade.
BlueMesa @ 96
I agree. Kinda makes you wanna think again about waterboarding. No, I didn’t mean it.
Regardless whether Scotty gets punished or not, methinks Lil Miss Weathergirl, Dana Peroxide, should pay close attention.