Congratulations on swallowing Bob Murray's cuddly patriarch act so easily. Now three others have died and it's apparent that maybe you should have been asking questions from the start about Murray's history as a union-hating loon and whether his concern for the safety of the mineworkers was quite the priority it should have been.
Stop right now and as Digby recommends, watch Harlan County, USA.
There will be a quiz later.
Login Here
Share This
Spotlight
Howdy, Jane!
Zed?
Jane!
Yeah!!
Yeah, as to the press, I’ve asked why it is some institutions even exist, they do such an utterly crappy job.
Wish that more people would read The Pump Handle blog and other health policy blogs.
Why is it that our blogs are so marginalized?
OT: Fire in the old Deutche Bank building in NYC. It was on fire on 9/11. It is unoccupied I believe, and I think it is under “deconstruction”.
Also perhaps watch “How Green Was My Valley”.
Wouldn’t George W. Bush be responsible for these deaths? He made the recess appointment against all advice and even the good-for-nothing 109th.
what we have lost
http://www.nytimes.com/2007/08.....ref=slogin
And there is still much to be learned from “The Grapes of Wrath”.
Best short Jane Hamsher essay. ever.
Concern Over Wider Spying Under New Law
By JAMES RISEN and ERIC LICHTBLAU
I messed up above, sorry
semi OT - 181 Chinese miners trapped by flooding
Hi Jane. Howdy y’all.
Jane, did you hear my cousin is going to be a reporter too?
Oh, and Elite Media, Arianna Huffington and some furry Internet persona have a thought or two to add.
Oklahoma kiddo @ 11
Love that book…
Really love the old movie with Fonda…
I believe the situation in the novel regarding the migrant population is really relevant to today’s “out-sourcing” of US jobs…
I think you know what I mean….
MATEWAN (1987)
by John Sayles
Detailing what came to be known as the “Matewan Massacre” in the midst of the bloody and contentious nine-year unionization Coal Wars (1912-1921).
It should be apparent by now from NAFTA, CAFTA, WTO, outsourcing, the DLC and the “third way” that the American worker is obsolete. And who is the Democratic front runner? A Leadership Team Leader for the DLC. Good Gawd.
Ed*ard Teller @ 12
I don’t know, it’s awfully difficult to narrow it down to a top ten for me..)
But..But… I have a 5000 sq’ house, a monster SUV, and a 60″ plasma teevee. What would a 30 year old documentary about striking Kentucky miners have to do with me?
This is what 27 years of Reagan/Bush/Clinton/Bush economic policies have brought us. Exploding steam tunnels, falling bridges, collapsing mines and nearly unstoppable climate change. Not to mention the destruction of the labor movement along with American middle class. And now the entire world economy is on the verge of collapse.
And I’m afraid it will get worse before it gets better, so hold and get ready for the ride.
Handling of mine disaster questioned
I am pro-choice. Not just about the issue of abortion. I am pro-choice about not having the DLC ram their candidate down my throat or up my…
N=1 @ 6
For those of us on each of the overlooked fronts, it can be astonishing to experience how long it takes to attain critical mass (tipping point) much less critical masses (accountability).
Part of it is a numbers game, to be sure.
Part is a proximity game, as well.
People don’t really care until it affects them or someone they know (and care about). Or until it becomes painfully obvious that they could be affected next (infrastructure is a good example, workplace safety another, both of which are now gaining on, or surpassing, terra)
Keep pressing onward, N=1.
Seems that the tipping point is right about now…
Will someone please name the last honest and competent president who did lasting good things for the American people.
What exactly will the tipping point be? I’m curious. How far down does our country have to go before the citizenry feel the pain, in a collective sense, to cause an uprising? Are we that busy? Are we hypnotized?
fyi-dr. porter is still downstairs in the blue america thread, answering questions in the order they were submitted-he’s on #123………..make sure to go back later and read it……is this a record?
AZ Matt @ 23
Tula Connell pointed out that while he was a mining company executive, his company’s safety record was twice as bad as the average. Bush installed him using a recess appointment, because even Congress couldn’t vote for him. This appointment happened after the Sago disaster, which you think would have been enough of a wakeup call for any Administration.
kinmo @ 27
Bottom of a collapsed mine seems to be less than half way there…
Jonathan @ 26
Clinton was honest and competent, not sure what he did good for Americans, unless you credit him with a vibrant economy. I’m having a hard time thinking of any positive Clinton legislative achievements. JFK would have to be the most recent one who fits the bill.
(Yes, I’m skipping Carter. He wasn’t very successful domestically.)
Haven’t seen Harlan Co. yet, but it’s on my Netflix list. I saw Matewan just a couple of months ago. Great film.
It’s a shame films like these aren’t stocked in the local video stores. Not in my neck of the woods anyway.
dmac @ 28
Actually, he’s up to #127 now, which was Chris Bowers’ question(s). His answers I quite good, I think.
Cujo359 @ 29
Not in this Maladministration! When the foxes are put in charge of all the coops, and they devour all the eggs along the way… it shouldn’t come as any surprise…!!! ;-)
OMG, I cannot afford this pop quiz
from Amazon
Jane, just loved The Iceman Cometh, love the caption, love the botox information. And on a radio guy no less, could there be anything more insanely narcissistic?
I am confuzled. It seems like there’s a lot more regular Americans than mine owners and rich people. A lot more people with regular jobs that can imagine themselves getting hurt or killed at work. So how do the rich people manage to convince so many regular people that doing what is best for the owning class is better than doing what is best for the MAJORITY of the rest of us?
For brutal mining movies I’d recommend Germinal, based on the Émile Zola novel. It takes place in France in the mid-1800s but captures the class warfare and brutal conditions of mining quite dramatically.
Traditional Media is complicit in all manner of Republican evil. The dissemination of war propaganda and union-busting are favored themes b/c the Media belongs to Rupert Murdoch, Jack Welch and a handful of other lesser- known Republicans (whose numbers are in decline as bigger fish like Murdoch and Welch buy them out).
It appears that progressives are beginning to understand that the Media are not bumbling fools at all, but that they willingly and intentionally disseminate right wing propaganda b/c they are so ordered by their corporate masters.
Walter Kronkite was by most accounts a tool and a right-wing hack until he found it beneath his principles to further disseminate pro-war propanganda. President Johnson said that he lost the American Public (and lost the war) when Kronkite made disparaging remarks about the Viet Nam War.
It seems beyond hope today for any Media Bobblehead to bite the hand of his master in the name of principle.
If anyone does, he will be a genuine patriot.
Apologies to Olbermann. We need a Network News converted Kool Aid drinker.
JFK. Excluding Carter of course. Broke the back of the steel industry. “Centers of Power”.
There are others.
puppethead @ 31
I remember JFK and he didn’t fit the bill. I think RFK would have made the cut. I think you are stuck with Clinton as the best fit.
SnarKassandra @ 37
Thomas Frank’s “What’s The Matter With Kansas” is a good place to start.
Saw the immediate aftermath (bodies being brought in station wagons to a high school) of a mine explosion on December 23, 1951.
Orient #2 Mine, West Frankfort, Illinois.
A cold, drizzly Sunday. Very, very grim
119 killed. I was 6.
Mining is inherently dangerous.
The only protection for miners is a union.
But…but…but…reportering is hard work! Do you really expect the media to interview a suspicious mine owner who seems like a Scooby-Doo villian AND interview experts on geology and mines? I mean, they’d have to make AT LEAST two phones calls, and they might have to, like, drive to some completely different place.
It’s is difficult to judge JFK. He only was not permitted, as we know, to live through his first term. He was cut down by Limbaugh and O’ Reilly types.
Given the death toll in Iraq, and the rising death toll of miners, when do we start looking seriously at alternative sources of energy?
SnarKassandra @ 37
People are more concerned about lesbians getting health care benefits than they are about workplace safety.
PeteCO @ 46
Half of Florida will be underwater before it happens.
Frank Probst @ 47
Do we point out to them that when the vote for repukes then nobody gets health care?
Frank Probst @ 44
And they might have to talk to smelly working class types.
The impression is that the MSM is ‘corporate’, and will not change. At least not in time to make a difference in our children’s lives.
PeteCO @ 50
Gross! Someone should complain to the hotel staff!
Frank Probst @ 44
Or they could read the newswires. The AP and Reuters seem to have worked out what was really going on pretty early in the process.
Still too much work, I suppose…
SnarKassandra @ 37
Tough one, Cassie.
My short answer is: our current, money, money , money, MONEY driven electoral/campaign system has perverted the Founders’ ideal of “one person, one vote” to something much, much closer (too $#@$%4 close) to “one DOLLAR, one vote” (or any dollar-unit you choose.). Oh, and large corporations with lots of money are somehow considered “people” on many levels. Thus, the wealthy have far, far more say over what the gov’t does and, naturally, the Owning Class has only its OWN best interests at heart.
As for why so many “ordinary” americans fall for the ‘thuglican lies? Well, don’t we all want to be rich and powerful one day?
FunnyDiva
Jonathan –
LBJ.
You know, I read that the asshole running MSHA came from Pennsylvania’s Office of Deep Mine Safety. If true, I bet he was a Ridge appointment. Even with the lucky Que Creek recovery, that was an accident that never should have happened. What a shame. Pennsylvania once had the finest deep mine safety operation in the world. They were actually flown to Poland and Britain to assist in rescues and did massive consulting for other programs. Also in Ohio and West Virginia. I fucking hate the reThugs. They fuck up everything they touch. Everything.
SnarKassandra @ 37
Cassie, they own the media. Most people get their news from TV. All they get to see are republican talking points edited to look like news, and celebrities with substance abuse problems. They did not have to let Murray dominate the mine collapse story, they chose to. The corporate media owners like nice simple parables that keep Americans dumbed down and confused as to what is truth and what is fiction.
Frank Probst @ 44
Matthew Wald of the NYT is one notable exception. He usually reports about air safety (ground, passengerand air traffic control), energy production, and infrastructure. He responds to readers’ emails, and he just contributed to one story about the mine situation that was an exception to the traditional media’s ignorance of miniiing safety.
Ammunition Shortage Squeezes Police
[My bold added]
I guess we can’t fight them anywhere else because we are out of bullets.
SnarKassandra @ 37
Dear SnarK,
I like your talent for seeing the big, important questions that ought to be obvious but which few people seem to see — if they do see them, then they often skip through the answers as though the answers were easy: I have the feeling that you do not do that.
So, if these were other times, I’d suggest that you think about becoming a researcher. However, grants being what they are these days (non-existent, or as good as), I can’t point anyone in that direction in good conscience.
Figuring out the real answer to your question is thesis material for a historian, followed by a contract for a best-selling book.
When you find your answer, it will show us how the country was lost (only for a while, God willing).
Anyway, that’s my $.02 worth.
PS That’s Tom Ridge from Erie fucking Pa, who was running the “Department of Reich Security”.
SnarKassandra @ 49
Right but we get to see the Ten Commandments posted in public buildings as that’s more important…
Shell @ 55
LBJ probably fails the honesty portion.
It is said that by the time you are 16, you have had received enough information to be able to see things really clearly for a very brief time, then you spend the rest of your life tangled up, trying to remember what you used to know. Something like that.
dakine01 @ 60
Then we should point out all the commandments that Bush and the govt are breaking all the time.
LS @ 62
Then 15 yr olds SHOULD be running the govt and old people should be sitting in social studies class!
Cassie,
My short lesson on mine safety and politics.
Candidate A, who is very bright, wants very much to get elected.
Getting elected takes money, as you will find in 2032 when you run for president.
Legislation, which Candidate A believes is needed to protect miner safety, is being debated on the Senate floor.
Candidate A is a senator.
Candidate A gets a call from Mr. X, who is very wealthy and very deep in the shadows. He urges Candidate A in very blunt terms, which Candidate A understands, to vote against the legislation.
Candidate A announces on the Senate floor she will vote against the legislation because it does not go far enough to protect miner safety.
LS @ 62
so that explains it
LS @ 62
Like I used to know not to write, “you have had received”…;>
Jonathan @ 43
Something Jared Diamond pointed out in his most recent book is that mining is a tough business in which to make a profit. That fact creates incentive to take all sorts of shortcuts and risks. For the workers, there needs to be some countering force to make sure those things don’t happen.
As we’ve seen, while there is a government agency that’s supposed to regulate these things, it’s possible to short-circuit it.
I’m not a fan of unions, but I don’t think I’d want to work in a coal mine without one.
SnarKassandra @ 64
Pretty much! Some…15 year olds…
SnarKassandra ‘08!!!
Jonathan @ 26
Hmmm…can we narrow that down to the last president who did lasting good things for people? I’d say FDR, although most of it is dismantled by now…
SnarKassandra @ 64
Patience is a virtue, Cricket…!!! ;-)
Cassie, one of the ways the elites keep the “people” voting against their own interests is by offering what is mostly a false premise, that they can by hard work join the elite. They also employ fear and divisiveness, to keep middle- and working-class groups fighting each other while they keep going to the bank. They also control the media and decides who has access to how much information.
The only cure is to educate yourself.
CTuttle @ 72
The teaching goes both ways…
LS @ 7
It was across Liberty St from the South Tower. I am not real big on the beauty of buildings but always thought that was a nice looking building.
LS @ 74
Oh so very true…!!! *g*
Why is a lame-duck administration trying to push this?
WASHINGTON, Aug. 18 — Broad new surveillance powers approved by Congress this month could allow the Bush administration to conduct spy operations that go well beyond wiretapping to include — without court approval — certain types of physical searches on American soil and the collection of Americans’ business records, Democratic Congressional officials and other experts said.
http://www.nytimes.com/2007/08.....ref=slogin
SnarKassandra @ 64
Go, Cassie, Go!
Maitwan.
Hazel rules.
TradMed also misses this point: mine owner Murray is a great buddy of Mitch McConnell, Senate Minority Leader, who is married to the Labor Secretary, Elaine Chao, whose agency oversees the Mine Safety and Health Administration. She is the boss of Stickler, in other words.
Here’s more:
dakine01 –
I know I am jaded, but NO president is completely honest. No, not even Jimmy Carter.
Did LBJ completely screw up with Viet Nam? Yes. But did he pass some great social programs? Yes. In fact, at one of the signings for a civil rights law, he said, “I have lost the South for a generation.” If ONLY it was ONE generaton!
So — to me, he was the last president to pass long-lasting, meaningful law for progressives. (And remember, even FDR had his drawbacks.)
SnarKassandra @ 63
Unfortunately, many (most?) of the tru-believers are convinced that all they have to do is shout “I BELIEVE IN JEEBUZ” at the top of their lungs all the time and all will be forgiven, no matter what their actions may be.
It doesn’t really matter to me who gets in. Hillary or Obama. ‘Cause they know what’s best for me.
JDM @ 56
Dude, you need to calm down and quit being so fowl mouthed and rude everytime you make a comment.. Try catching flies with honey.
dakine01 @ 61
As is keeping children safe from the gay agenda, and punishing anyone that looks or believes differently from us, righteous, God-fearing folk.
Guess that’s another part of my answer: There are an awful lot of average people out there who are just plain narrow-minded and mean-spirited. And the ‘thuglican party is expert at playing on their prejudices and vindictiveness.
FunnyDiva
The “Majority” are strapped for money. They live check to check to maintain whatever they are maintaining. The “powers that be” frighten them into believing that any “programs” that could help other people, will cost them their cash flow in the form of taxes. The Majority would need to hang on to their meager cashflow, so they can eat, rather than risk losing cashflow; which they can’t afford to lose. The “powers that be”, who don’t have to worry about losing a little cashflow, actually get “rewarded” for towing the lie by not having to contribute according to their income bracket. Ultimately, no one wants to help anyone. It’s every man for themselves. The “powers that be” fear, because they too are brainwashed, that if they give up anything, they will immediately regress back into the cauldron of the majority…besides, they just don’t seem to care.
Real reporters would get in the face of a guy like Murray and refuse to allow him to pontificate and give self serving statements. A famous newspaperman whose name escapes me said his job was to “afflict the comfortable and comfort the afflicted.”
Job requirements for a presidential candidate:
ambition to be president that overrides all else
huge loads of political smarts
a huge rolodex and knowledge how to use it
some blackmail cards
some promises that will never be made public
a willingness to do whatever is necessary without any conscience
nothing else
Our Elite Media cuddle up to Murray for the same reason they spit on John Edwards: They are either The Man themselves, or desperately want to be.
You could make the argument that 15 year olds are running the country. Emotionally speaking, but that is really an insult to most 15 year olds. Speaking only for myself, I could benefit from some social studies classes. That is one of the things I like about the lake, I’m always learning something new.
jim o’connor @ 89
Finley Peter Dunne
Phoenix Woman @ 90
PW — In my opinion, it’s Them and Us. Plain and simple.
LS –
I say BS to that argument. Is what you said true? Yes, of course. But why are they so cowardly? It’s as if they are working at McDonald’s and can never get another job.
Look at all the ancient old dweebs in the Senate! They are rich. They have more than enough money already to support their living family for life. But still they MUST get reelected. WHY? (That senile old goat from Alaska comes to mind.)
JDM @ 61
Ah, not so nice to see you again. Why must you speak like this every time you comment?
LS @ 87
My sister has stated for years that most people are about three paychecks away from the street.
Shell @ 94
Power and greed.
LS –
I agree. And no one else says it, but it IS a form of mental illness.
Shell @ 98
I’d say it is a human “vice”.
Without Eleanor I don’t think that FDR would have done as much as he did for progressive programs. She was his conscience. That is why I think it is important to know as much about the wives of the men running for office as the candidate running for office, or husband, if the candidate is a female, because if a marriage is a true partnership, the spouse can have a great impact on a presidency. That is why the Republicans hated Eleanor and Hillary, they knew they were influencing policy.
jim o’connor @ 88
I F Stone, if memory serves.
In fact, this country is awash with mental illness. Just take the religious right — SO against gays, yet so many (most?) of them are closet cases.
Why don’t Americans start paying attention?