Memorial video for aide to Katrina victims. This is wonderfully done, and haunting...
Scout Prime has gone down to NOLA for the second annual Rising Tide conference of NOLA and Katrina bloggers, community and political activitists. As Scout says, there are going to be some fantastic speakers on a host of important issues, including the ever-present questions on the engineering (or lack thereof) of the current levee system around New Orleans.
And with Katrina aide incentives going to build luxury football condos in Alabama, rather than for housing projects or other relief for the 45,000 potentially carcinogenic FEMA trailers in the NOLA area alone (yes, you read that correctly -- heckuva job, Chertoff!) and the rest of them all along the Gulf Coast, one has to wonder what the Bush Administration's priorities really are? Or maybe that's already abundantly clear:
Concerns about formaldehyde contamination have existed for more than a year, but FEMA was slow to react, and when it did, downplayed the health risk. But lawsuits, environmental groups and warnings by independent experts and doctors have pushed FEMA to seriously re-evaluate the risks....
At such high levels, he said people, especially children younger than 6, are likely be affected. (emphasis mine)
The fact that FEMA has been re-selling these trailers isn't exactly going to make things easier, now is it? I'd say some Congressional oversight is in order, but with Joe Lieberman and Susan Collins at the helm of the Senate's homeland security committee, I'm not exactly counting on any materializing there, now am I?
I listened to a poignant story the other morning on NPR -- an interview with a Katrina survivor who has an incredible amount of grit and determination, something that I have seen and heard from others in this situation as well. (Some of whom are our readers who have shared their stories with all of us over the past two years.) My heart just aches for her, and for everyone still battling to get back on their feet, only to be knocked down again and again by the morass of red tape (something which the luxury condo builders were able to buy their way past with lawyers and PR personnel, no doubt).
If you watched Spike Lee's "When The Levees Broke," you heard the mournful yet strong music in the background from composer Terence Blanchard. He has taken that score and expanded it into a jazz requiem which is amazing. (You can listen to excerpts at this Amazon link.) The music will pierce your heart with its fierceness and sorrow, and haunt you well after the fact.
There will be a reckoning in this country some day for the shameful way we have treated our fellow Americans in the Gulf Coast. For their neglect and the willful disregard of conscience and lack of hard work, and instead going for the expedient PR maneuver and lack of substance that is the hallmark of the Bush Administration.
Shame on us all but, truly, shame on a leadership that has failed to actually lead when our nation needed them most.
We need real leadership and real compassion, not some trumped up play-acting and klieg lights. The Bush Administration has learned no lessons from their failures here. God help us all of there is another disaster like Katrina.
It took them more than a year to act on highly toxic and carcinogenic FEMA trailers -- more than a year! (Thank you Rep. Waxman for actually having hearings on this issue.) And then they tried to hide the dangers and their own incomptence until they were forced to own up to it by the courts. The levees are likely flawed, and people who have filed lawful claims are still dealing with the appallingly Kafka-esque paperwork nightmare that has been set up to prevent them from getting paid claims, from federal and private insurers alike.
Our own government, killing these people softly after all they have already had to endure with the losses in Katrina. Before you rush off to the rest of your day remember: this could be you...
Login Here
Share This
Spotlight
Christy!
EPU’d OT (and “deux”) Richmond @ 154
Rome.
Awww. Just missed that zed!
A friend who just came back from a week’s visit to New Orleans said there’s been little change in the Ninth Ward since Katarina. Wealthy and middle-class whites are now the majority in the whole city–excluding Algiers.
On New Orleans. Has anyone ever done a cross-check of people known as missing/dead and the list put together by the Hallburton affiliate who was charged (exclusively) with finding the dead. My assumption is that they were hired for this with the idea that they could keep the “losses to a minimum.” Hmmmm
That memorial video is dramatic.
And an indictment.
and let us not forget, kkkarl rove was responsible for the rebuilding of new orleans
Once again you put up a powerful post.
It is unconscionable to me that this is still getting ignored by BushCo, like it is going to go away or something!
If anything, it’s a matter of time until NO gets slammed again, finishing off the vulnerable city.
Bush should have to retire to the ninth ward, if he doesn’t just go to prison. Then I bet things would start happening.
perris @ 8
Even though KKKarl is a long-time Tejas resident, I doubt he knows where NOLA is. When it comes to real-world stuff, I don’t think KKKarl could find his own ass with both hands.
perris @ 8
mission accomplished
Me @ 5:
Katrina…
sporkovat @ 3
we need the image of bush playing guitar while new orleans flooded juxtapose against nero playing violin while rome burned
The whole trailer “thing” was a scam. Top dollar for poorly made mobile homes, with out gassing insulation and particle board and no-bid contracts. The sight of 11,000 white mobile homes, sinking into the mud near the Hope, AR airport was/is a picture of ultimate govt corruption.
Prairie Sunshine @ 11
soo sad that that’s actually the truth, the mission was accomplished.
perris @ 13
At least Nero created fire-fighting brigades. (Seriously, he did.)
Bush is more likely to be creating fire-starting brigades.
Federal programs indeed:
Steve-AR @ 14
I think Teddy Roosevelt’s reputation was largely self-promoted, but, from what I’ve read, if this had happened on his watch, I think you could just about guarantee that Michael “Heck of a Job” Brown would be living in one of those shithole trailers for a good long while before he ever got to come up for air.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=akWgObxKnog
there could be better ones out there, but this came up first.
Biodun @ 5
Gentra-cide.
-GSD
Good morning Christy.
Thanks for shining the light in this direction.
This is from July 31:
And more noise than action:
Scout and I are going to keep in touch while she’s at the conference. A lot of the bloggers in the region have some amazing content — which you can see if you click through the Rising Tide link above.
Here’s the original AP story on them condos:
coffee spewing time)
dumbest headline of the year:
WAPO front page website:
Will Rove Pen A Tell-All Book?
GSD @ 20
Has the racial cleansing of NOLA been enough to affect state-wide elections in La? I am sure Rove et al saw Katrina as a sign from god for the Republicans forever plan.
Any discussion of the postal rate hike for publishers? Click for action items.
P J Evans @ 16
yeah, they are called U.S. Attorneys.
And let’s remember this:
OT - (just a heads up - upcoming news)
9th US Circuit of Appeals Hearing(s)
Today, Aug 15, 2-4pm PST (San Francisco)
Appeals Court Battle Over NSA Surveillance
And these developers and buyers of these condos are some of the loudest screamers about Mercedes driving rich welfare moms.
Steve-AR at 26 — I’m not certain anyone knows as yet. The last election had a lot of absentee votes and a whole host of problems in determining who was supposed to vote where. It’s a mess.
We have a guy here in town who was shipped up here as a “refugee” and ended up staying in WV and opening a wonderful cajun restaurant here. He talks about going back, but everything is so incredibly difficult — and for the folks who stayed…all you have to do is listen to the NPR story of this one woman to know how tough it has been for the not-so-wealthy.
Biodun @ 24
Y’know, most times I think that most of the people in this country are pretty decent, know the right thing to do, and want to at least help out those in need a little bit, if they can.
Then I read something like this, and I wonder WTF this country has become. Yeah, this has happened throughout the country’s history, but, maybe, never this brazenly, and never with so much assistance from the government.
It’s the true, abject face of corruption.
Steve-AR @ 26:
And this:
In regards to FEMA. A good Bush tactic practiced well in the past:
Run a bureaucracy so poorly that tax-payers get disgusted in it’s efficiency and when leaders propose to privatize it, no one is there to stick up for the program because it was crumbling already.
The problem of course, started when the leaders put in muppets and retards.
It’s been a good trick. FEMA has lost cred due to it’s poor leadership and distortion of purpose.
cancer_cures at 35 — I do think that is a lot of the problem here. When you have an agency run by people who think government is the problem. And they outsource a lot of its functions to cronies who are in it for the cash, and not for doing the job well…this is what you get.
What a freaking mess. And I shudder to think how bad things would be for the next disaster because they have literally learned nothing from this.
And also this not-very-surprising tidbit:
Just saw this at the ABCNews site:
http://blogs.abcnews.com/thebl.....us-st.html
U.S. Eyes Homegrown Terrorist ‘Clusters’
Brian Ross, Richard Esposito & Maddy Sauer Report:
U.S. law enforcement officials say they have identified more than two dozen “clusters” of young Muslim men in the northeast United States who are on a path that could lead to homegrown terror, ABC News has learned.
“Any one of those clusters may be capable of carrying out a terrorist action that will result in fatalities,” Rand Corporation terrorism expert Brian Jenkins tells ABC News.
In a report to be made public today, New York City Police Commissioner Ray Kelly concludes the 9/ll attacks were an “anomaly” and the most serious terror threat to the country comes from clusters of “unremarkable” individuals who are on a path that could lead to homegrown terror.
[shortened by mod]
cancer_cures @ 35
Christy linked to an incredibly poignant NPR story by Michele Norris with a Katrina survivor named Sharon White, who has been stuck in some starkly dead-end scenarios since losing her home in the hurricane. Norris has been doing some fantastic mental health issue stories for NPR, and is an exception to the general rule that NPR’s news reporting is going downhill.
On economic and demographic effects:
Good morning from L.A. Thank you for this heartfelt post, Christy.
I’ve commented many times here about the folks I know along the Gulf Coast, as well as in Baton Rouge, St. Francisville, & Slidell who opened their homes & mustered every available resource they could to help Katrina survivors.
All continue doing it in spite of the morass of red tape & bureaucratic hoodoo involved in getting any kind of government cooperation (even so much as permits necessary to work on your own house reconstruction).
Lack of organized post-crisis management from the top causes those in need to do without, do for themselves as best they can, or go to charity & kindness of others, much of which is tapped out @ this point in the recovery efforts…
“When a federal government is in power that thinks government is inherently bad, you get just that- bad government.”
The 2nd anniversary of Katrina drowning our Gulf Coast approaches soon. May it be marked in the media by more than “specials” on CNN & the rest of cable news touting their own coverage.
Have to go in to work. Read you all later.
impeach - impotent - impotus - impatient
ET at 40 — Michele Norris has been following Sharon’s plight since Katrina. The stories that she has done on this woman have been as amazing as the amount of spine that Sharon has. I have been keeping track of these stories because she reminds me so much of my fiesty granny (who we lost several years ago) — and I keep hoping that things will get better for her. This last one really broke my heart. And I’ve heard the same sort of story over and over from others in the region as well.
Halliburton itself is not the problem. We need companies like Halliburton for reconstruction.
However, it’s overpriced and contracts can take longer than expected. Normally another more efficient company would get bids and contracts, but due to white house connections, halliburton is chosen.
It’s allowed to run inefficiently because there is no one there to cancel their contracts.
And another problem with Halliburton/White House connection is if Halliburton requires another 25 million to finish a New Orleans project due to poor project management, wastage, or cutting a little off the top, the White House will reward it with the next 25 million no question asked. Basically, inefficiency thrives because poor management is rewarded and unchecked.
I don’t worry. The DLC will take care of everything and everybody. They’re a “progressive” outfit. That’s what their web site says. And that’s that.
On environmental effects:
BTW, Christy:
Thanks very much for this post. I really don’t want to take your wonderful and thoughtful and compassionate posts for granted. I’ve come to expect them–and gotten so used to them.
Biodun @ 34
I am now thinking that all of the “incompetence” by this administration is by design. Bush is the moronic, psychopathic front-man for some very smart people. The “mis-steps” in Iraq, Katrina etc. are now looking like highly planned out-comes. Where are these people headed? The combination of discrediting of the Federal Govt, gutting of the economy, policies that are likely to cause an economic crash, a police state and endless war. As the pattern unfolds, it is looking less and less like a series of random fuck-ups.
The report identifies mosques, bookstores, cafes, prisons and flop houses as what it calls “radicalization incubators” that provide “extremist fodder or fuel for radicalization.”
Well - as it should be. Attendance at a mosque, going to bookstores and cafes are all well known “attempted thought crimes.” So glad that someone’s looking out for me. It’s scary out there.
And having radical thoughts in a prison? Unacceptable - those misfits should be sent immediately to, err, prison.
Flophouses are well know to be places where poor homeless people hang out - and those people all seem to have *some* kind of gripe… thought criminals, all of them.
We must stop these evil people before they start to think.
Thanks for the post on a subject which still makes me burn with anger. To add to the good news, we have TS Erin now, and TS Dean, which now appears to be headed more westward towards the Yucatan — God knows that the Gulf Coast couldn’t handle much else right now.
Biodun at 48 — Thanks. This really is one of those issues that infuriates me and makes we want to sit and have a good cry at the same time every single time I do a post on it. Because it never seems to get better — and that is beyond frustrating. I can’t even imagine what itis like for the folks who live along the Gulf Coast and in NOLA.
The luxury football condo bullshit is such a craptastic symbol for all of hsi mess — these condos are far inland, and have nothing — NOTHING — to do with recovery efforts. And yet they are touted by the Bushies. And yet, the people who desperately need housing couldn’t afford to live there — they’d be lucky if they could get a job doing groundskeeping or cleaning there because they’d have to find transportation back and forth every day that far inland to work. Jeebus…
cancer_cures @ 35
A Reagan tactic, actually. But Bush certainly has polished it up hasn’t he?
Jeebus, friends, from EW
Christy, I cannot get an e-mail to go through to you. I’m in WV–where is there a wonderful Cajun restaurant–it’d be worth the trip
Steve-AR @ 49
I started coming around to your school of thought about September 21, 2001 - the third day of the anthrax episode.
BTW, speaking of wikipedia changes, this one probably won’t last. It wan’t up there a month ago:
Letters containing anthrax spores were mailed to several news media offices and two Democratic U.S. Senators, killing five people and infecting 17 others. The crime remains unsolved but is strongly believed to be the work of domestic right-wing extremists.
loubarr at 55 — try ReddHedd AT aol DOT com. We’ve had some attack issues of late and the e-mail has been a bit wonky as a result. Our tech folks are working on it — sorry for the inconvenience…
And Mayor Ray Nagin of New Orleans ain’t no saint neither. As Douglas Brinkley’s The Great Deluge: Hurricane Katrina, New Orleans, and the Mississippi Gulf Coast convincingly pointed out, Nagin was in cohoots with the (white corporate) powers that be before and even after Katrina, to the detriment of African-Americans.
FishGuyDave — I know. The weather folks keep saying that this season looks to be a very active one again, and every time I hear that, I hope they are very, very wrong…
Steve-AR @ 49
Absolutely. Results always favor the Republican Party. Incompetence is a ploy to avoid accountability while painting the government as inherently flawed and incapable of producing results.
Think this has anything to do with Hastert’s exit?
After all, his work here is done, too.
(h/t to PW, posted link at TNH)
Biodun at 58 — The more I look at all the issues involved, the more I am positive there are no saints in any of this except for the folks who are just trying to rebuild their lives by working their asses off to get back on their feet…there are far too many folks in it for what they can get who ought to be leading instead.
jayt @ 50
This is scary. People are being labelled as terrorists because they do things people do all the time. Obscene.
Christy Hardin Smith @ 57
Sorry to hear about the attacks, Christy. So it goes.
I’m so glad to read a post about Katrina and Nola. It is a crime against humanity and citizens of the United States.
After having been a flood survivor 6 years ago, I can tell you that the trauma stays with you. I still have frequent flood dreams that are terrifying. Personally, I would not be able to go back and live in the 9th Ward for that very reason. It is obviously not safe.
The crime is that the flood was caused by unsafe levees, which the government knew would be breached should such a storm occur (Hurricane Pam).
The very worst crime is that American citizens were left to die of dehydration before our very eyes.
The ongoing crime is that no one has been held accountable. Those in charge of the oversight are complicit.
“Those in charge of the oversight are complicit.” Paging Senator Lieberman……
MayDaze @ 60
Who benefits? The “incompetence”, increasing KIAs in Iraq, probable economic crash,and higher gas prices are likely to damage both political parties and could prove fatal to the Republican party. If the US economy tanks the major corps are going to be hurt. I think big business has supported a political agenda that has gotten out of their control.
well, suprise of all surprises
the president is actually going to write patreases reportuhyup
SHOCKED I tell you, SHOCKED
it’s feeding time guys, me needs to go and feed
c L8tr
I can’t really say anything about NOLA and Katrina. I just get too damn upset. I’ve been through some flooding too so I know 1/1,000,000th of it, but everytime I get back to this subject I just cannot, cannot, cannot understand why this could happen here. And why nothing is being done about it. I guess we just don’t *need* NOLA. It’s worse than the terrorism if you ask me.
And I know that this post is incredibly depressing. My apologies to all and sundry for making the mood so dark, but I needed to say all of this before a pounding headache descended…what a freaking mess.
Has Joe Lie-berman ever even been to New Orleans in his capacity as chair of the Senate Committee of Homeland Security?
retirin’ in five @ 66
That was my exact thought, too.
Have we mentioned the Mississippi gulf coast yet? It gets even less coverage than NOLA, and is in equally bad shape. Except for the CASI*Os, which have all been rebuilt.
retirin’ in five @ 66
And the Senators who enable him.
Christy Hardin Smith @ 70
That’s OK. We need this dose of reality check no matter how depressing. In contrast to BushCo who invent their own “reality,” their own “truthiness,” we live in a reality-based world.
I am angry and depressed today.
I want my country back.
Biodun @ 75
Most of the news about the state of our country is depressing. The solution? Take action.
Betsy at 73 — Yes, I’ve done posts on it as well if you look in the Katrina folder. It’s tougher to find information on how things are going, only because it hasn’t gotten as much coverage.
Often I wonder what presidents like Dwight Eisenhower, Teddy or Franklin Roosevelt, or John Kennedy would have done after a disaster like Hurricane Katrina.
I’m too young to remember them, but historically I can watch video of their speeches at times when the country needed to hear their voices the most. At times when the country needed direction. At times when ordinary people would put their lives on hold to help.
Two years have passed. Does Bush seem interested at all about the reconstruction of Hurricane Katrina? Where’s his voice? When I think of Bush and Katrina, I think of this picture. Far from the problem, disconnected from reality, safe from the danger.
Oh yeah, remember that Bush was golfing during Hurricane Katrina. And definately off topic, but Bush was reading childrens books through 9/11. I don’t see how our neighbors on the right see him as a leader.
Biodun @ 71
Ha HA HA HA Ha, er, sorry but you get my drift.
Prairie Sunshine @ 74
Paging Senator Reid, too.
Steve-AR @ 67
I’m not sure most of the perpetrators think any further ahead than the next election. The true believers in laisse-faire capitalism are fine with disruption - it creates opportunities for creative investment, don’tcha know…
I think it is also very important to remember and revisit what actually happened at the time, and hold the government accountable for their crimes directly against suffering and dying human beings, before some statutes of limitation run out the clock or something like that.
I don’t understand why major action in that regard has not occurred, unless I’m just unaware of it. The proof is all there.
TribeScribe @ 61
Ok, now I’m really sad AND really, really, really mad too. Does this mean that DeLay knows MORE about these matters today than the people trying to do oversight? I bet. Super-duper-secret my ass.
Resignation. That is what I see and here from New Orleans. Like before the fall of Cambodia, the people celebrate today as best they can and look out for each other. They know everything is precarious and are ready to relocate, somewhere.
I was born and reared in the Ninth Ward and spent all my school years in that ward. My parents and grandparents were born and reared there so we have an old history with the area. For those from the area, we lived between St. Claude and the River. My family lived on France and Dauphine Street along the Desire Streetcar line (now Desire bus). We have generations buried in the cemeteries in that local.
My sister and her family live in Metairie one block from Lake Puntchartrain and two minutes away from West End, totally devastated by Katrina. Because of lack of doctors and limited medical facilities plus damage to her and my sister’s home, my Mom was placed in a nursing home.
The storm was terrible but the response to it is worse. It’s been killing, draining the life out of people drop by drop. Everyone is suffering. There are the usual “carpet baggers” looking for some opportunities. It was so bad that my family just struggled on their own rather than get ripped off by outsiders over-charging for mediocre services.
Within five months of placing my Mom in the nursing home, she died. The medical staff just was not available through no fault of their on. Everyone was doing their best. My sister and I just accepted the reality of the situation. She and I spent a day together visiting all the places in our childhood and early twenties that we spent with our family. All was destroyed. We wept together, giggled at old times, and just hurt. The entire population feels this way. We are just a typical family there.
People have pride and they try to make the best of a terrible situation. They have been deserted by their fellow Americans, the entire Bush Administration, the hopeless state and local politicians and Federal agencies. They are left with opportunists coming at them from every angle. They have little strength left to fight them. They just struggle to survive. My sister says everything is falling apart around them. They are barely holding on by their fingernails.
And yes, they just had neighbors over for a fish fry party.
Maydaze @ 60
there was some fictional anecdote I heard once about how a criminal gang should have at least one disposable idiot to take the blame if they get caught. If he gets left behind by the getaway car, no worries.
but the (D) party can’t even stir itself to bring impeachment proceedings!
complicit.
Hi gang, it’s been awhile since I have had the time to read and comment. Going back to the FEMA trailer issue: No surprise there. The “manufactured housing” industry has had issues for years. Off-gassing of Formaldehyde is just one of them. Mold is another. (Bad joke- in NOLA, how could you tell?) And then there is structural integrity. I could go on and on about how friends of mine have consulted with the good fabricators of mobile homes to improve their product, but you know that FEMA got a good deal from the “bad” manufacturers and didn’t even think, much less cared, about the living issues inside those crates.
Quakergirl, thank you so much for sharing all that. I am sorry for all the losses you and your family have been through.
And let’s not forget Barbara Bush the elder saying that the poor folks of New Orleans are better off being located elswhere, implying that the city was a dump anyway.
Unrelated: One “expert” was quoted days after the hurricane saying “New Orleans naturally just wants to be a lake.” Memorable.
Welcome back Gnome. We missed you. (This is TexBetsy.)