Given the Administration's abysmal track record for poor planning and ignoring consequences, we should be grateful that at least someone is thinking through the consequences of Iraq withdrawal scenarios. But since Ambassador Crocker claims he hasn't heard about any real plans, even though in a country "gripped with fear" we might need them, it would seem appropriate for a member of the Senate's Armed Services Committee to ask about this.
Apparently, however, if the member's name is Hillary Clinton, she's not only not entitled to ask about such essential contingency planning, she's in for an insulting and publicly leaked rebuke from the Pentagon, written by an incompetent, dishonorable neocon hack whose nomination the Senate never approved. On the other hand, if you're a Republican and your name is Richard Lugar, you can raise the same issue and not only are you not rebuked but everyone assumes you're a wise, serious, and responsible person.
Of course, planning for a withdrawal contingency probably seems unnecessary for someone like General Petraeus, who was gung-ho about the chances for success for every plan the White House neocons wanted. But it's telling that, while Petraeus tells Hugh Hewitt how well the surge is working, he and Odierno are telling Congress that they can't possibly make an assessment until November.
While no one ever accused Eric Edelman of being the brightest bulb, it doesn't seem to have occurred to his Pentagon superiors that it is probably not a good idea to insult a respected Senator who sits on your budget committee and who is doing the job the American people expect of her [h/t Biodun for Digby link] in watching out for the welfare of America's armed forces. And then there's that interesting scenario in which she just might become the Commander in Chief. It's called contingency planning.
Just in case you missed KO's special commentary on all this . . .
DoD Photo of Under Secretary of Defense, Eric Edelman
Login Here
Share This
Spotlight
Caw, caw!!
caw?
These people disgust me. I fear we will see much more of this before November 2008. Maalox anyone?
1) Withdraw all war funding
2) Impeach Cheney, Bush and Gonzales
Did you see that NYT poll about Hillary? Like 83% of Repugs disapprove. Her and her husband have been the victims of 15 years of a sickening campaign to ruin their name. Repugs may be sick of Bush, and they might entertain a vote for Obama or Edwards, but they will NEVER vote for Hillary because of this. And it doesn’t let up. Listen to the press around these new “biographies” about her. It’s just one slur after another. I just don’t know how she could overcome this serial hate campaign in a general election.
Caw, scarecrow. Thank you for this. Kerry has just come to Hilary’s defense, saying that the administration will say anything, do anything, twist anything to avoid responsibility.
Different standards apply to Senator Clinton. Especially by Chris Matthews whose disdain for Clinton is so apparent. Instead of focusing on where she stands on issues, Matthews obsesses on her husbands past behaviour and how she looks and whether she is warm and cozy.
Hey Matthews can you please get off it and focus on the issues.
Here’s my Q about withdrawal. The road routes to Kuwait could easily be cut off–by Iran, by Shias, who are fighting each other around Basra. So is the airlift capacity large enough to evacuate U.S. troops?
Impeach.Now.
Just watched KO again.
Where does he broadcast from, New Jersey?
I’d like to go there and thank him, personally.
The fact is the military plans for EVERYTHING, for every contingency. For the Pentagon to attack Hillary for insisting they do they jobs is totally insane, the terminal gasp of the total politicization of everything under this regime.
From Wikipedia about D-Day and Eisenhower’s sense of responsibility.
Does the fact that Eisenhower thought about and even planned for failure and was ready to take responsibility make him a surrender monkey, bent on demoralizing his own troops?
Interesting discussion at EW’s place, in the comments,(linked above) re whether or not the Wilsons are now time-barred from pursuing any further actions (other than appeal of this specific ruling, of course).
i thought that from the get-go most of the suit was past the statute of limitations, in that it complained of specific actions, which culminated in the publication of Novak’s piece. Wilson’s lawyers, however, didn’t file the suit until the anniversary of *the column*, missing the limitations period for the actual actions complained of.
IIRC, there was a conspiracy count (Count VII?), which would have had to stand in order to keep all of the prior counts legally viable.
And the Federal Torts Claim Act is now time-barred too, I believe.
eCAHNomics @ 8
No, not by a long shot. Yet another reason why the neocons’ antagonizing of Iran is so insane.
eCAHNomics @ 8
We would need to pay off the Shias and Iran to grant us safe passage out of the country. One of the things they will insist on, no doubt, is that we leave our military hardware in their hands.
Scarecrow, another really relevant post. Thank-you….
Good morning everyone. :)
I just wanted to say that what I am seeing are more and more people talking about what/who is going wrong in this country and less and less people are supportive of this particular White House.
This is great, we’ve spent years just trying to be heard and now the words are spreading everywhere…
OT already ;)
I know this has already been pegged… (Folks here are blindingly fast with new info :)), but I’m a little curious, how it common to get ‘food poisoning’ when you are a vegan? and doesn’t ‘food poisoning’ usually last only about 48 hrs?
There is a lot of political ’stuff’ going on right now, we need all the good guys up on ‘The Hill’, they all need to stay healthy….;)
(CNN) — Democratic presidential candidate Dennis Kucinich remains hospitalized Wednesday in Ohio after aides say he suffered a severe case of food poisoning.
Kucinich spokesman Andy Juniewicz said the Ohio congressman started feeling ill Sunday before flying to Florida for a campaign appearance. He became sicker in Florida, and was forced to cut the trip short to return to Cleveland.
http://rawstory.com/showarticl.....pitalized/
We just got in from a fast trip to Dallas, actually it was Fort Worth. We had a little meeting last night with some family (and friends) Demo organizers. We are determined to make Texas and Oklahoma blue.
As to Senator Clinton. Republicans, you all just keep on doing what you’re doing with your ugly tactics. Because it’s driving certain of us into the Hillary camp. We are warming to the idea of President Hillary Clinton.
I’m going for a swim out back. Then I am going to fix pan-fried potatoes, bacon, fried cornbread and virgin mary’s for me and my gal.
jackie @ 15
Well they used to use small airplanes but…….
Perhaps the cherry on top of Edelman’s sundae of hypocrisy is that Sen. Clinton asked for a briefing on withdrawal plans, not a “public discussion” — he’s the one who chose to discuss it publicly, two months after her request.
That beyond anything else proves that this is solely intended as a dishonest smear, not as an honest (though insane) criticism.
Government by the Republicans, of the Republicans, and for the Republicans needs to vanish from the Earth sooner rather than later.
Kathleen @ 7
I thought it was really interesting that Mrs. Edwards thought it was a good idea to attack Hillary, but then Hillary says, “Okay, if it’s spouse warfare you want, I’ll just send mine out to respond.” Only her spouse may be the most popular and effective counterpuncher in the country. I think the other candidates better rethink that strategy.
Good morning Oklahoma Kiddo.
jackie @ 15
Food poisoning: organisms can be found in fecal-contaminated soil. Remember the earlier spinach contamination? Chicago has just had a food poisoning issue, too at a food festival - it was also traced to a vegetarian dish. Not unusual any more with FDA agency failures to inspect and test produce.
jackie @ 15
1) don’t think being vegan affects probability of getting food poisoning at all (either making it more or less likely) - same risk as everyone else.
2) depends on the cause of the ‘food poisoning’. e. coli O157:H7, staph, salmonella,… can be anything from mild to deadly.
disclaimer - i am not a md
My congressman and senators rarely reply to email questions is this normal for other people?
For example, I asked why after billions of dollars don’t people in Bagdad have electricity?
Kiddo at 16, O’siyo!
“We are warming to the idea of President Hillary Clinton.”
Um, are you feeling all right? In fact I agree that this over the top bashing of her carrying out her Senate duties might very well provoke a backlash and grow support for her campaign.
Altho if I go farther out on the limb, I might wonder if the fix is in, she is the designated President-elect, and they have already concluded a deal about how far the Dems can go up against real power, so that this is part of their propaganda to sway the election. Nah. Probably not.
Let’s remember that Condi Rice wanted to be Secretary of Defense instead of Secretary of State at the beginning of BushCo’s second term. This is from the link in one of Christy’s posts yesterday:
My bold. Imagine that.
jayt @ 12
The broader message is that in the last two weeks, the Bush Administration has moved to seal off every avenue of accountability — access to the courts, subpoena/exec privilege, open defiance — there is only one remedy left, and it’s now staring Congress right in the face.
I hate to break to you guys, but our side is winning, Bush is on defense and losing ground everyday. He can’t declare martial law in a country of 300 million people, with the majority of the military half-way around the world. A military, by the way, who doesn’t support him. This thing is over for him, all he’s trying to do now is make it to the end of his term. All we have to do is keep up the pressure.
Good Morning Scarecrow.
I have become thoroughly addicted to your regular analyses of subject matter the administration keeps trying to hide under their frightfully lumpy carpet.
So… you think folks at the Pentagon have been trying to influence the upcoming elections? ya-think?? Hm-m-m. Wonder who put them up to that? Just can’t leave that bunch alone for 2 seconds. *sigh*
Thank you for all your fine work untangling the mess that is Washington these days.
Your writing is clear and concise, and right to the point.
Isn’t it a little scary that the integrity of our federal government now depends on popular support for — and Democrats’ ability to communicate to the public — the importance of checks and balances, equal branches of government, and congressional oversight?
I’m worried that in our current depraved media environment, it’s just going to come off as petty partisan politics on both sides. Give me reason to hope for something better!
Boston1775 @ 10
He was in Los Angeles last night. He normally broadcasts from Secaucus, NJ, but lives in Manhattan.
On NPR a couple of days ago, I heard a piece about how the US can’t reasonably be pulled out of Iraq for two years. The reason? Removing the tanks, Humvees, construction equipment would take that long. See they have dust and microbes and other icky stuff that could pose a threat and ruin the ecological balance of our country. And it would take two years to clean them all up to a safe level. See Cheney is really really concerned about the environment after all!!!
“That? Oh, that’s just the Goopers. They’re always tying things down on their bus and driving it real fast. Don’t pay any attention to them…”
Oklahoma kiddo @ 16
Go O.K. Oklahoma is more purple that people think. Push hard and tip it. Just watch out for caging, and the reduction of voting machines in your poor districts before the next election.
Think about ordering this documentary about Ohio’s 2004 selection
http://howohiopulleditoff.com/
and ordering Bob Fitkaris book “What happened in Ohio”
You will learn a great deal and possibly cut the election thiefs off at the pass.
This nation has gone fucking nuts. Nuts. The Nazis have reconfigured and have taken over the highest levels of power in the US.
-GSD
Scarecrow @ 25
“Give Impeachment a chance”
Cheney’s Iraq (PNAC) plan…the only one that matters…is to “FAIL FORWARD”
IRAN here we come!
They should not shut down the Congress for an August recess. Bush can do too much mischief.
Japandrew @ 11
But that was by someone who actually “thought” about what he was doing…
snowbird42 @ 36
How do we get August declared “Put it on the table” month?
Scarecrow @ 19
I thought Elizabeth Edwards attacking Hillary as not being as strong as John on women’s issues was questionable.
I like John and Elizabeth Edwards a lot. I appreciate the stands they take on poverty. But to say that John has a better record on women is, well, huh?
Then, in the campaign ad, he’s looking, hard, into the air with a flag behind him while Elizabeth says that he’s optimistic but can look at the tough issues (don’t have the exact words).
All I can tell you is at that moment it seemed a little ridiculous to be implying that Hillary can’t deal with the tough issues. In my humble opinion, the Edwards campaign needs some work.
Nothing will “humanize” Hillary Clinton more than for her to be attacked unfairly (ie, not for her policies) and for her to be seen as singled out. It worked FOR her in her first NY campaign, when Lazio pulled some slimy stuff in the debate — pushed many people who were wavering right into her camp — and where is he now?
boxer @ 26
Boxer is dead on. However there is a variable that can stanch the blood flowing from the Bush body politic and that is a military escalation in the region…..Namely Iran.
That is the ace in the hole for Bush/Cheney, but it is also the final straw. They know that they are up against the wall and need a miracle……And we know these clowns believe in miracles.
-GSD
P.S. If you want to know where the military stands, notice that 70% of the donations from US military have been to anti-war candidates with Ron Paul and Barack Obama leading the pack.
Arianna Huffington on the Diane Rehm show on the News Round Up. Now
1800-433-8850…drshow@wamu.org
http://wamu.org/programs/dr/
OT - Hastert to resign?
GSD @ 33
I think the correct term is national socialist. And the way it worked is to use the corporate structure to provide the ’socialist’ discipline.
In otherwords, Nazis found a way to harness corporate interests to funnel wealth and power to the issues of political expediency. This is exactly what Bush and Cheney are doing.
And the Bush family has always been involved in such a philosophy. Just google harriman nazi prescott.
Oklahoma kiddo @ 16
M-m-m-m! Blue OkeyTex with a side of pan-fried taters! *drool*
Darn you OKK, I’m tryin’ ta lose a few lbs.
BTW, Surely do appreciate your toughlove approach to politicians. Sounds as if you & I are right about even on Hill. In fact, I remain of the opinion that NONE of the repub. candidates rises to the quality of the least attractive of the Dems. Not even close!
Scarecrow @ 38
time for a call-in the keep the Senate in session from now until 2009 to prevent any recess appointments.
Also, no approvals for any Federalist Society members for anything ever.
Boston1775 @ 10
I think usually NJ (though they’re moving msnbc studios to the city and consolidating with nbc) but last night I believe he was in LA area where he had been at critics meetings of some sort for interviews. tweety has also been out there as well this week
Perhaps we should plan on helping the Democratic congress stay in session all through August so that Bush can’t pull any shit?
Maybe a month long sit in around the clock to let Bush know that he’s being watched too?
-GSD
The main MSM front page web sites do not even mention Bush’s latest power grab from the WaPo (CNN, MSNBC, etc.) MSNBC is even a partner w/ WaPo, usually posting the lead stories, so as to get wider distribution. Nobody is paying attention to what this means.
twolf1 @ 43
I wonder if Larry Flint has the goods on Denny’s Grand Slam….
snowbird42 @ 37
They should not shut down the Congress for an August recess. Bush can do too much mischief.
Personally, I’d like to see protesters on the Capitol steps when they return saying “Welcome Back - While you were gone, xxx# number of American troops Died, xxxx# were Injured”…
Or something like that.
Maybe drop the “Welcome” bit.
Hastert might leave??
John Laesch for Congress!
Neo-con quotes you don’t wanna hear: “You move on to the next war with the nukes that you have…not the nukes you wish you had.”
GSD @ 47
The Tillman hearing is on August 1st.
Digby in Salon last night:
Jackie @ 15. The worst case of food poisoning (salmonella?) I ever got was from a salad bar in a hotel in Ft. Lauderdale. I thought I was going to die. Unwashed fruits and vegetables are a common source of food-borne illness.
Scarecrow @ 38
We could petition the Lord with prayer,
or we could petition Congress. and with paper petitions, not virtual ones.
GSD @ 47
Greetings Scarecrow and all pups, Yeah, I got some shoe leather that’s just itching to taste some D.C. pavement. The sit-in part will be tough on my back, so I’ll just lean. As long as it takes. Anyone with me.
dead last @ 49
omg, puleeze! haven’t even finished my cuppa. *blergh*
dead last @ 49
That would be hilarious.
jayt @ 50
Personally, I’d like to see protesters on the Capitol steps when they return saying “Welcome Back - While you were gone, xxx# number of American troops Died, xxxx# were Injured”…
Or something like that.
Maybe drop the “Welcome” bit.
In the Senate’s all-nighter, did anyone mention that for every month the Iraq decision is postponed, 100 U.S. troops die, and are those who favor postponing the decision happy to take the responsibility for those lives? I thought that was the most powerful argument, but saw no coverage that anyone mentioned it.
GSD @ 47
Of course you don’t mean Bush literally, because we know what he’ll be busy doing all August- there’s much brush to clear, you know!
i can’t picture denny in my mind without recalling “that” scene in the 1st Harry Potter.
You know the one - floating up up & away….
Redshift @ 18
sounds like contemptible behavior to me.
This is OT, but here’s something from today’s Post I have a feeling emptywheel will be digging into soon enough. Three as yet unnamed companies that won Heimatsicherheit bids for non-working radiation detectors:
http://www.washingtonpost.com/.....id=topnews
eCAHNomics @ 61
That is such an important point. Delays cost lives.
Biodun @ 55
Ah, thanks for the Digby link; I’ve added it to the post.
Lou Costello @ 52
Remember how unhappy the Chimpenfuhrer looked after meeting with Putin? I still think that Putin told him to look deep into his (Putin’s) eyes down into his soul once again and realize that if he invades or bombs Iran that it will unleash a sh*tstorm so bad that it will make Iraq look like the cake walk the neo-con artists thought it was gonna be.
Putin/Russia AND China would both probably launch against us if we pull something there.
Sandman @ 21
by any chance are they Republicans? it is decidedly not normal to receive no response to a formal inquiry (email or writen) to a Congressman. After all, they work for you. Perhaps a visit is in order the next time they are in town.
I know attacking Clinton on national security issues is big news, but I think we really just want to know about her relationship with Bill. Do they still sleep together, or do they have separate beds? And how much do her haircuts cost? You know, really important stuff like that.
I’m not much of a Hillary supporter myself, but for me the best reason for a President Hillary Clinton is it would drive the wingnnuts batshit crazy for eight years.
Thanks to all who responded to my question re; food poisoning etc :)
OT, isn’t Fitz on NPR tomorrow?
think it’ll be baseball-related?
Excellent post and thread
I must load my van for a craft show. Hopefully Ill be selling to the top 1% this weekend who wont notice anything but the rise in the market.
eCAHNomics at 61 “In the Senate’s all-nighter, did anyone mention that for every month the Iraq decision is postponed, 100 U.S. troops die…”
Durbin did in the early hours of the morning iirc. Surely there were others.
Zalmay Khalilzad in an Op-Ed piece in the NYTimes today:
Here he contradicts Bush, who said earlier this week that “international organizations” (pace: the UN) are incapable of resolving the situation in Iraq.
TiredFed @ 68
Mine (Rs all) usually give me some reply but it is one to two months after the original sending. I don’t cut ‘em any slack on that as they still spout their BS and I reply that their answer is non-responsive and identify why it is non-responsive.
dakine01 @ 67
is it sick or shameful to feel relief that one’s own leaders might be held in check?
omg, how far we have slipped during this awful awful administration…
snowbird42 @ 72
go forth and prosper ;->
1. I still will not vote for Ole Gutless & Spineless Hillary under any circumstance. But, her question posed to DoD was a fair question.
2. Nor do I interpret the crappy response as a slam on Ole G&S. The answer, to me, just seems like more of the “slap-in-the-face” response everyone in the WH gives to ANY inquiry made by Congress.
3. Contingency plans DO exist. Hell, DoD has, somewhere in the files, plans for invasion of….Antarctica! Doesn’t mean we’re about to invade the land of penguins…but DoD does plan for anything and everything.
I suspect that, due to the political heat on such plans re: Iraq, the details are held about as close as our nuclear codes! But…those plans exist. They’re somewhere at DoD.
Ghostman
GeorgeSimian @ 5
Neither do I. If she is nominated, one hopes that those Republicans are so disgusted with their own party by then (I know, if not now when, but we know these folks are painfully slow on the uptake) that they will just stay home.
bluejeansntshirt @ 58
maybe in a few weeks, i’ve some health problems to resolve first. gotta give it some thought… but, i’m very tempted. thanks for asking…
It is funny but the more the wingnuts open up on Senator Clinton the more my sympathies go with her.
They are going to make her a winner after all.
Besides, imagine Hillary and Bill using executive privilege to go through all of the Bush papers that have been classified and using executive privilege to open the books to the public on the most embarrassing matters that the Bushies want hidden for decades?
-GSD
MUST read…MUST
I’ve been raising this alarm for quite a while now…this is the person that drafted the articles of impeachment against clinton that is telling us we must impeach this administration
please read the entire article…my bold here but there is MUCH more
Olberman was PISSED!!!
He sure looked as mad as I feel.
Impeachment is the only solution.
dakine01 @ 75
Yessss!!! ;->
I’m googlin and googlin and can’t find HRC’s speech on the Senate floor in the wee hours. I didn’t even see it on her website.
She looked whipped, every bit of her age, gravely serious and capable. Where is the link?
It would be ridiculous to hide this speech because of her looking tired. Ridiculous.
TiredFed @ 69
ha ha! first time i went to senator kerry’s office (with a couple of firepups), i wasn’t even permitted to leave my letter with the security guard.
(it got better… but only because RevDeb knew of an aide in his DC office)
The Republicans are driving people out of their party by the droves and droves.
Pretty soon it isn’t gonna matter about their base because their base aint gonna be more than 20% of the electorate.
-GSD
GSD @ 83
Now that would get me on the Clinton bus
These people are either mind-numbingly delusional about this occupation or they have sold their souls to the devil so cravenly that they are forced lie until the bitter end. Although, after all is said and done, I really think most of ‘em would crack.
egregious @ 73
Thanks. Didn’t see any coverage of it.
sandflea @ 91
I’ll go with “selling their souls to Satan” for 1000.
-GSD
Scarecrow @ 67:
Thanks for the h/t!
brendan @ #65
Remarks by Homeland Security Secretary Michael Chertoff and DNDO Director Vayl Oxford at a Press Conference to Announce Spectroscopic Portal (ASP) Program Contracts
Release Date: 07/14/06 00:00:00
For Immediate Release
Office of the Press Secretary
Contact: 202-282-8010
July 14, 2006
Secretary Chertoff: Good afternoon, everybody on this very hot day here in Washington, D.C. I have with me Vayl Oxford, who is the director of our Domestic Nuclear Detection Office.
As I think I have said previously, the single biggest threat we worry about, in terms of protecting this country and securing the homeland, is the threat of a weapon of mass destruction. And at the very top of the scale is a nuclear device or a radiological
http://www.dhs.gov/xnews/relea....._0953.shtm
Hmmm…everything I’ve read about Reid and the summer recess all year long is that at the minimum he plans to call congress to session (every ten days?) to prevent recess appointments. It seems to me that Congress has a pretty high chance of working through August.
Adie @ 59
How come Matthews never brings up Hasterts weight? Matthews is endlessly bringing up Gore’s weight.
Sandman @ 21
Edelman and Electricity, I have a link, from the heart of darkness, Council of Foreign Relations. Edelman says “There is plenty of electricity.”
_____________
There are many challenges as we move forward in helping Iraq economically. Much of Iraq’s infrastructure requires repair or replacement, and additional effort is required to reduce a tax on critical infrastructure. These are slightly exacerbated by a skyrocketing demand for electricity, a challenge that political reform and economic openness have helped spawn. I noticed this myself, by the way, when I flew into Iraq a month ago in the early morning hours — about four or 5:00 in the morning as we came down — and the country was lit up from north to south. So there’s plenty of electricity, I can tell you.