Sometimes when I'm in the car and a song that I absolutely hate comes on the radio, I'll turn it up. Why? So I can hate it in detail. I get that same feeling reading Glenn Greenwald's merciless take-down of President Bush and his coterie of sycophants and demagogues in Tragic Legacy, Greenwald's latest book, which chronicles how an overly simplistic, black and white, Good vs. Evil mentality has destroyed the Bush Presidency and by extension, inflicted heavy damage on the Republican party, the United States, and the world.
Initially, I was a bit skeptical about diving headlong into another 300-page tome detailing the third act of the pitiful "Flowers for Algernon"-style psychodrama that's currently playing out backstage in the Bush Administration. You and I already know that George W. Bush is a man of intractable stubbornness, hot and cold running religious fanaticism, and truly breathtaking ignorance, a combination that makes him singularly unsuited for his current employment status. Why get an upset stomach and a rage-induced headache learning about it in even greater detail?
And yet, I was dead wrong, and I knew it before the end of the first chapter. Tragic Legacy is, in fact, a highly entertaining read, if you, like me, enjoy the sensation of (in the words of Jane Austen) "reveling in angry pleasure" at seeing so insidious an enemy taken down point by point and left huddled in the smoking ruins of his own hubris by the end of the book.
An alternate title for Greenwald's second book could be, How to Talk to a Rightard About President Bush (If You Must). The book is divided into three parts. Part One is a detailed study of President Bush's jejune, Manichean view of the world, as expressed in his own speeches, writings, and in the voices of his peers.
It is not a kind portrait. To many of us, President Bush's decisions over the last six years seem to emanate from no fixed set of values. We have wondered from time to time if he is losing his mind, hitting the bottle, or is merely adrift, making sweeping policy decisions on the spur of the moment, based on the sketchiest of details and an imperfect understanding of the issues at hand.
Greenwald provides us with an illuminating view of a President completely unencumbered by nuanced thought. His whole notion of history and America's role in the world seems to have been cribbed entirely from 1950's cowboy movies and "Sgt. Rock" comics. In George Bush's world, his friends, admirers, and supporters are all on the side of "Good", whereas anyone who disagrees or opposes him is on the side of "Evil".
This binary view of the world permeates everything that the President says and does, and he is constantly surrounded by a troupe of Neoconservative toadies who know that they can convince him to sign on with even the most outrageous and ridiculous policy initiatives by presenting the issue to him drawn in huge bubble pictures that would be comprehensible to a child, and as long as they are sure to couch the question in terms of a struggle between Good and Evil.
Nowhere is the danger of this kind of reductive thinking more apparent than with regards to US policy toward Iran, which takes up the second, and longest, part of Tragic Legacy. In this section, Greenwald lays out in chilling detail how White House policy seems to be headed inexorably toward a war with Iran. No matter how foolhardy this course of action may be, the "Decider" has included the nation of Iran in his armies of "Evil" and seems bound and determined to strike at any time, regardless of the consequences. As has been documented by numerous sources, Bush has come unmoored from the considerations of the real world (i.e., public opinion, the Pentagon, and sticks-in-the-mud like the Iraq Study Group) and decided that only "History" can be the proper judge of his legacy.
An armed conflict with Iran is possibly the greatest danger we face from the Lame Duck Bush Presidency. As is illustrated in the book, as well as in today's "We're just starting the surge!" display of petulance, George Bush is at his most bellicose and defiant when his back is against the wall. No amount of empirical evidence will dissuade a man like President Bush who is completely convinced that he is on a personal "Mission from God".
In reading the book over the weekend, I was lucky enough to have my reading punctuated by further updates about the defection of multiple members of the GOP away from Bush's Iraq policy. Perhaps being disowned by his own party apparatchik will begin George Bush's slow and painful re-integration into the real world. I don't have quite enough faith in that prospect, however, to sit by and wait calmly until the end of his term and hope that somehow, everything is magically going to be alright.
It's a shame that thus far not a single Dead Tree Media outfit has seen fit to review or feature Tragic Legacy. This book is an explicit elucidation of the madness driving this administration, and yet it never falls into the trap of being an extended rant. Greenwald calmly and methodically builds his case with exquisite care, proving that his writing on the printed page is every bit as pithy and trenchant as it is on the computer screen, then surprises you with dry, bitingly funny asides like this from p. 88:
Bush's evangelical conversion seems beyond doubt, given the profound life changes it facilitated, most particularly the abrupt and total cessation of what was, by all accounts (including his own) a rather severe addiction to alcohol. But in another, equally significant sense, replacing an alcohol-fueled life of unbridled hedonism with a fervent evangelical certainty can be seen as a lateral, rather than a vertical, move.
Indeed. And heh.
If you don't have a copy of Tragic Legacy yet, get one. If you have a copy and haven't read it, what are you waiting for? It's not like it's some piece of Ann Coulter tripe to be purchased and displayed, unread, on a moron's bookshelf. Greenwald has crafted for us and the world a moving, cathartic, and insightful book that hopefully will give the non-blogging public a new level of comprehension as to the dangers we face under an unbridled chief executive whose view of the world is not much more nuanced nor a great deal less fanatical than that of, say, Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, who also just so happens to believe that he's on a personal "Mission from God".
Ignore this book at your peril.
Login Here
Share This
Spotlight
Zed
zunoed?
hiya!
zed!
Ah, missed it by THAT much…
That damn shoe phone again.
TRex!
yippee! in the first 3 plus the little facebook thingie finally showed up.
quaintly out of the running.
boing - back double somersault tuck, over-rotated - large splash - oooooo
g’evening everyone, TRex, that post was worth waiting for :)
Howard Dean
Speaking of our Dear Leader …
Click here.
G’head.
I quadruple-dog dare ya.
Bring yer own brain bleach. Two gallon minimum.
six posts inside the first two minutes.
we try harder.
Moment of silence, please, for editorial cartoonist Doug Marlette, killed in an automobile accident earlier today.
cant afford the but look forward to the discussion
Greenwald is clear and articulate.
His recognition that there are two definitions of “conservative: (the Barry Goldwater limited government idealist type being one, and the followers of people who call themselves being conservatives being the other) was spot on.
His comparison of conservatives to communists(Karl Marx utopian idealists being one type, and collectivist despots being the other) was also spot on.
Enriching insights.
At a minimum, squelch lines for GOP boors at summer barbeques.
damn this one handed typing
burnspbesq @ 12
NO!
Go Glenn! Was very impressed with How Would a Patriot Act? Have Tragic Legacy on the way so can’t really discuss it yet.
I’d donate it to the public library when I’m finished…except our entire county library system closed in April. Biggest library closure in our nation’s history. Just another casualty of the Bush Regime and the Iraq War.
I hope egregious doesn’t take that personally…
Good evening dear friends.
I am only a chapter or so into the Greenwald book so far. Please don’t spoil the ending.
OK, now you inspire me to read. I have the book, just haven’t gotten to it yet.
burnspbesq @ 10
Demotivation for Gopers.
I think Bush and his enabler are somewhat schizophrenic in their views on Iran. Or at least the enablers seem to be.
This is a comment I posted on one of Christy’s threads earlier today but I think it has some pertinence for this one as well. Discussion was about neo-cons wanting to take Iran even more than Iraq:
The same Neo-con warhawks who then conspired with the Iranians holding our citizens as hostages until immediately after Carter left office so that the release would not happen on his watch.
The same Neo-con warhawks who then sold arms to the Iranians they profess to hate in order to raise laundered money to pay for arms for their puppet governments in Central and South America in direct violation of law.
They do and don’t want war with Iran. They mainly just want excuses to build Halliburton’s trade and keep oil markets in flux.
argosfalcon @ 15
got a bum hand?
Great post, TRex. But I don’t need to be urged to buy A Tragic Legacy. I got it last week (from Amazon, via the FDL connection)and can’t wait to start reading it. I enjoyed doing my little bit to help run it up on the New York Times bestseller list. I wonder how we could get TradMed to take notice?
Sorry, I don’t want to read any more about The Colossus of the CodPiece
I want to seek out the people, organizations and all other scum who would enable this asshole to take power and support his effort to convert our nation into a Corporate Slave State and then….
I want to destroy their ability to ever do this again. And guess what?
I am not alone.
Evening all.
Well things are beginning to look a bit grim here in the northern Rockies. High today was 90 and it is supposed to be in the high 90s for the next two days before hitting the 100s again over the weekend. Normal highs for this time of year are 82. All this heat, combined with low humidity, below normal rain for the last two months, and no rain in the forecast has raised the fire danger to high. This is quite early in the season for that. The heat is also adversely affecting the fishing as several rivers in the area have been closed to fishing between 2pm-midnight (when the water temperature gets above 70 trout start dying). This is the earliest ever that this has been done. Usually does not happen until mid-late August (if then). May put a real damper on my camping plans for the summer.
No global warming here. Nothing to see here, just keep moving everyone.
TRex!!! In classic style you boil it down to a succinct quip!
“How to Talk to a Rightard About President Bush (If You Must).” *g*
By the time you’ve had enough, it’s too late.
TRex, thanks for reinforcement. I bought it but have been half afraid to open it. Didn’t want to get more depressed than i already am about our Thief-N-Chief, but now I’m eager to start it. Then give it to my mom who is involved in local politics in Wisc. Maybe I should buy several more : )
darkblack @ 29
Oh that is SCARY!!!
burnspbesq @ 10
Make that a 3 gallon minimum.
Evening, gang.
Whew! Running around like a crazy man, tonight.
How is everyone?
TexB @ 19
Is there an end to this madness??? Evening, Ma’am, Suz, DrD, AK…!!! *g*
darkblack @ 29
The chunder from The Blunderer.
-GSD
MLW has this um heartwarming story of a mother tiger grieving for the loss of three newborn cubs. Cute overload alert.
Loo Hoo. @ 24
Well lets say I have a less than useful side, in some ways.
TRex @ 33
Good, thanks. You?
what kind of craziness is this?
It’s a given that Snowe will denounce the policy, so please give us till Sept to do that? And how many people need to die in the meantime? grrr ….
taking a break from gutting the bathroom, remind me to never try this again.
Had to put down the book, cuz my blood pressure was boiling i do believe.
OK, TRex, I’ll take “losing his mind” for $500.
CTuttle @ 34
CT, is there a madam on tonight? oh my, is she from dc?
I want to cry…
I’m also reading the “Rape of Europa” about the loss of all the art in Europe.
Chris
Am I in the lake? (New address!}.
-MS
Finishing up a first listen to the new Crowded House album.
Yes, it is wonderful.
The next few weeks will tell if GOOPERS are leaving Bush. Lets see the votes. My bet is they are doing a “Specter”, big talk and then vote with Bush. I hope I am wrong. If that’s the way it goes maybe the phenomenon should be called Ex-Specter-ation.
darkblack @ 29
Damn You, DarkBlack! Once again, I had to look!!! :P
burnspbesq @ 38
I am doing well. My son is back in town and will be back in my house tomorrow, where he will eat the summer’s worth of food in the 4 days he is here. :)
burnspbesq @ 10
Brain bleach! Whatever for? I thought it flattered them immensely.
bg @ 41
His mind checked out long ago.
burnspbesq @ 45
It’s on my list. Paste Mag. had a review of it in the latest issue, and they said “hey now, hey now, don’t dream, it’s awesome”
Anybody else have trouble getting in here tonight? Took me forty minutes to finally get this page to load up. Eh, I would have spent half the night, if necessary, gritting my teeth and swearing at the stupid toobz! TRex, you and the gang here at late nite are more than worth the effort.
Please note that Customer Reviews are now up for Glenn Greenwald’s A Tragic Legacy. Write one, or review those already written.
Excellent writeup, TRex; I too dreaded reading another compendium of Junja’s Greatest Hits, but Glenn’s book is fabulous. Best of all (for the rightards) he uses right-wing spokesbots very effectively.
Thanks for highlighting it for your Niters crowd.
CTuttle @ 47
With DarkBlack, you always know you will look and you always know you will regret it. I just grit my teeth and keep the industrial sized jug of brain bleach to hand. 8~p
How many here would vote for Dean if he were on the ballot?
Steve-AR @ 46
I agree. I’ll believe it when I see it. Stories like this: http://hosted.ap.org/dynamic/s.....TE=DEFAULT
MS in Park Slope @ 44
Thanks for the reminder. I haven’t played the Park Slope station in years (The F Line). I should check that out again one day. Very fond memories. In the cooler weather I love Grand Army Plaza on the red line though. Lived on 13th st after High School.
rwcole @ 55
Me!
rwcole @ 55
Who else is on the ballot?
Who are the front runners?
LoudounLib @ 51
I’m impatient. Downloaded from iTunes Music Store at 12:15 this morning. Couldn’t stay awake long enough to listen then.
newdealfarmgrrrlll @ 50
NO you cant tempt me to listen but the price would be high. Or how well can you bake (not wanting to be beaten by husband or boyfriend).
texb
Oh all the current candidates- and Gore.
Suzanne @ 42
Que?
TexB @ 59
How’s he doing in the polls?
How’s his fundraising?
What do the consultants say?
rwcole @ 55
I’d vote for Dean.
It was such a shame what happened to him last time. A bad mike. Stupid sound system added to to his zeal. I didn’t think it was that much of a rant. But, that’s just me. I tend to get more emotional sometimes than others like.
Re-elect Al Gore.
OT - So what’s with CNN? I haven’t been there lately but they don’t seem to post transcripts on their web site anymore, hmmmmm…
Anyway, Lieberman was shown on the Senate floor saying we are “making progress against the enemy in Iraq.”
Michael Ware then commented that Lieberman is living in a fantasy world, and, ah, there isn’t just one “enemy” there (as he laughed and shook his head) at Lieberman.
I’m not excited about any of the current crop including Gore- DEAN- on the other hand- appeals to me..
rwcole @ 62
Gore!!!
rwcole @ 55
primary or general election?
I’ll vote for whatever dem is the actual candidate in the general election, so if it was dean, I’d vote for him. Vote for him in the primary? Not so sure … but not sure who I’ll end up voting for — not happy about any of them.
lee5 @ 70
And I am happy about many of them.
I’d vote for Dean.
lee- primary
triciawrites @ 40
triciawrites, this is your reminder calling. Do not ever gut the bathroom again. Its rude and gets you talked about, particularly the screaming.
And if anyone asks why i haven’t posted to my blog here are the reasons:
1) The medical bureaucracy.
2) The story keeps changing by the hour. I have written the dayam thing three times only have a new datum arrive that scraps my previous line of reasoning. I sweartaghod, figuring out the sovs was MUCH easier….
3) The medical bureaucracy.
4) Turning my house into a hospital ward, on the government’s dime (the only good part)
5) The medical bureaucracy.
Other than that, the play was fine.
Back in a bit, y’all. Have to pick up Man-Cub from some activity or other, and then hit the market.
DrDick at 27:
When I traveled for my job in the late 90s I was fortunate enough to travel to western Montana. If ever there was a beautiful part of this dear country, that little slice may just be some of the loveliest.
The people I spoke with talked about the recent fire damage that had occurred just a few years earlier and the landscape was just beginning to recover (actually I was very impressed at how Mother Earth recycles herself).
Anyway, I’m hoping that this isn’t the beginning of a very hot and firey summer for you, but like you said it is only July.
flash of sliver in the sky, gone
triciawrites @ 66
Yes!
TRex @ 72
OK y’all. I get to do something new and exciting. After using my non-blog last week for posting links that Alfred said, I finally stumbled on a story today that I decided to actually blog.
(Confession, I told it as a comment on FDL an no one said a word, so I decided to look for a different audience.)
Anyway, I present to you (imagine drum roll here) …… the BetsyBlog
I just want a president who is not a crook. Of course, that does eliminate the entire republican party.
hmmm … texb — glad you are happy about the candidates. I haven’t managed to get excited about any of them, but would be willing to vote for any …
rwcole, in primary w/ dean vs. gore, I’d vote for gore. in primary w/ dean vs. current declared crop, I’d vote for dean.
again, in the general election, whoever is running against the repub ticket (and certainly not for the mccain/lieberman 3rd party ticket …)
TexB @ 80
and it comes heartily reccommended by Al the Spook. TexB is gonna kick Rethug butt and take names, just you watch!
dakine01 @ 23
Yes, you did, and yes it does. As the comment was addressed at on of my replies, allow me to footnote it.
‘Right. The same Neo-con warhawks who were incensed at the attack on our embassy in Iran after Carter, in a humanitarian gesture, allowed the deposed Shah to enter the US for medical treatment. The Shah whom they supported in his dictatorship.’
Predecessors of the neoconservatives destabilized the Mossadegh government in the 1950’s in order to install Reza Pahlavi on the Peacock throne…He was seen as being more ‘cooperative’ in maintaining the desired regional hegemony.
‘The same Neo-con warhawks who then conspired with the Iranians holding our citizens as hostages until immediately after Carter left office so that the release would not happen on his watch.’
More to the point, so it would be seen that Reagan was someone that the Ayatollahs and their fellow cultural revolutionaries were afraid of - That he had power where Carter was impotent. This was done for future considerations, which leads to…
‘The same Neo-con warhawks who then sold arms to the Iranians they profess to hate in order to raise laundered money to pay for arms for their puppet governments in Central and South America in direct violation of law.’
Those warhawks were equipping both sides in the protracted Iran-Iraq war…To them, why not profit from the mutual misery of undesirables, while creating ‘black’ financing for a pet war that the legislative branch had inconveniently outlawed?
‘They do and don’t want war with Iran. They mainly just want excuses to build Halliburton’s trade and keep oil markets in flux.’
They are terrified of the potential for Iran to declare an oil bourse, with its concommitant American currency devaluation in the petroleum marketplace…And crude oil can be extracted from under glass (say, the sort of glass created when a nuclear device is detonated in desert conditions) just as it can be extracted from beneath the whispering sands.
All that being said, I’m in general agreement with your premises but I differ with my perception of the underlying motivations.
Hawks in a panic
http://www.antiwar.com/lobe/?articleid=11264
argosfalcon @ 13
Make sure to ask your public library if it’s on their purchase list and, if not, why not!
No turning back now, Tex. You are a blogger now :)
Must be some sweaty sleeping going on at the Vitter house these days.
Poor Dave needs a kevlar jockstrap just to get a good nights sleep.
-GSD
First Glenn makes me a Salon Subscriber, now I buy his book. Maybe I should just start a moonbat welfare fund…
Yay Betsy! I saw the post about your blog tonight on FB. Excellent job!
Suzanne @ 81
“Generalization” I respect Lincoln Chaffee
TexB @ 80
The situation there is really grim and seems to be going backwards. I had an Afghan student this last year and she was a true delight. She was so eager to learn, a hard worker, and always so happy. I used to wonder what it would be like for her when she went back. Every time I see stories like this it tears my heart out.
althespook @ 74
Yippee! The Spook is in da house! We missed you.
The Euro has hit 1.37 on the greenback.
Custerfucking America into the next depression.
-GSD
am going to bed-gnite pups…….
but have wondered for months now, anybody read bible code 1 and bible code 2???????
read them a few years ago……….
passed around by bible thumpers as bible speak for bush’s right to the presidency……and the apocalypse…….cuz that’s what it’s about……and bush is a main player…….
a mathemetician figured out codes to the bible, entered names, bush, bin laden, etc., were among them….is an omen….divinity, omnipresent. etc….they were in there….that’s what people think………got it from a baptist/former methodist friend, she believes it, and so does all of her new congregation……….
read it, it’s freaky………..bible code 1 and bible code 2…..worth your money , really……..
and yes, i continue to take on all things on the dark side……….
nite, and suz, you can always do a better dive, don’t let this one get you downi………not all are perfect, but at least you do them………..
Kathleen @ 91
Kathleen, so glad you showed up tonight. I has posted a question to you downthread and have been waiting for a response.
And for the record, Kathleen, I am a lifelong Republican - and I say they are crooks.
The NL drought continues!!! Yee-Haw!!! 5-4 victory for the AL! Boston will host the World Series!!! *g*
Trex , thanks once again:
well, i am holding myself back now.
it is a pleasurable self-restraint.
i have Tragic Legacy
and you have excellently whetted my appetite.
however, i read slowly and i must finish Anatomy of Deceit first.
Then i must get caught up at The Next Hurrah.
i’m two days behind and Emptywheel has been rolling.
all the while i know i have glenn greenwald waiting.
the pleasure is in the anticipation.
i am in your debt.
CTuttle @ 1
Nice Zed, Dood !!!
Evenin’ all !!!
GSD @ 88
His wife was just mugging for the teevee. she’ll emasculate him in divorce court, which is more sanitary (and takes longer, for those into prolonged (legal) torture of miscreants…)
burnspbesq @ 75
Oooh, if there’s Man-Cubs available, can I order one for me and one for TRex?
Hey Petro. Good to see you!
Olbermann is truth-squadding Bush!
hey Petro :-)
CTuttle @ 97
Here, here! Hoping that the Sawx can keep up their 10 game lead.
No more “Bucky ‘Freaking’ Dents”!
NoahC @ 89
Advertise Liberally…!!! *g*