
[Steve Porter joins us in the comments today to discuss his candidacy for the PA-03. Please give him a great FDL welcome! As always, please stay on topic in this Blue America thread and please be polite. Thanks to Steve for dropping by to talk with us today. -- CHS]
I've been having a difficult time figuring out exactly who Steve Porter is. I mean politically I have it all figured out: brilliant, progressive true believer, hard-headed idealist, dot-every-i-and-cross-every-t idea man. But personally... well he was in a pop-rock band called Free Press long, long ago and he's written 18 books and he reminds me of my college friend Helen's father, the guy who helped me understand what it meant in the real world to be progressive.
The contest in PA-03 is a rematch of the 2004 race pitting a pretty pathetic Republican rubber stamp nonentity, Phil English, against Steve. The district gave Bush 53% in 2004 and English beat Steve 60/40, after blanketing the district in mud, going so far as to have a Young Republican Club denounce Steve, a scholarly Jewish professor, as a Nazi and a supporter of forced sterilizations. PA-03 is the extreme northwest corner of Pennsylvania. Erie's the biggest city. It's about 40% rural and it's overwhelmingly white and considerably poorer than Pennsylvania in general. The district could hardly be more poorly represented.
In fact when I asked Steve to tell me why he felt English is unsuitable for his job, he talked for 30 minutes, eloquently and factually, without coming up for air. "Phil English is a lockstep supporter of the war in Iraq," he began, "and he has never questioned anything about the misuse of intelligence or the misappropriations of billions of dollars."
Like so many Republican incumbents English's "I support the troops" line is just a meaningless slogan and he regularly has voted against extending assistance to our fighting men and women. Because of the composition of the district English tries to pass himself off as a moderate, which is patently absurd if you look at his extremist voting record and notice his complete subservience to the bought-and-paid-for Big Business agenda. An F/zero from DMI's analysis of legislation meant to help the middle class barely even begins to tell the story about English's disgraceful career at the public trough.
"Whenever there's a critical vote that the Bush Administration needs," explained Steve, "Phil English is available for his arm to be twisted. He always complies. Three important examples: HR-1 (Medicare, Part D)." [This is particularly significant in PA-03 because in 2000 English claimed he would fight for cheaper drug imports from Canada and it helped him win re-election]... He was the deciding vote on CAFTA-- after promising the Erie Central Labor Council that he'd vote against it. [Previously the AFL-CIO has supported English, although this year they have endorsed Steven]... And he was one of the deciding votes on HR-2045, the Budget Reconciliation Bill, the bill that is trying to fund the deficit created by the war in Iraq and tax breaks for the wealthiest Americans with cuts in funds for education, senior citizen housing, anti-drug school programs... It passed by 2 votes, 216-214."
But even with all that, Steve says the residents of the district have other things they are up in arms about. Out-sourcing of jobs has devastated PA-03 more than most districts and Alan Tomelson, author of Race To The Bottom, calls the district ground zero for the exportation of American jobs. "Phil English's votes on trade have cost-- according to the Department of Labor this district 9,700 jobs. "This guy has voted to give tax breaks to companies that outsource! He authored HR-767, euphemistically called the Homeland Investment Act, which allows American companies which have made profits overseas to bring the money back to the U.S. at a federal tax rate of 5.25%." If the companies had made the profit inside the U.S., the tax rate would be 35%. Obviously, this is a gigantic incentive for companies to ship business and jobs overseas.
Steve is well aware that English is a crook and a liar but he prefers to talk only about issues. The fact that English takes legal bribes from Big Business and then votes for the corporate agenda against the interests of his constituents is fair game. The fact that English has had more trips paid for by the taxpayers than almost any other member of Congress-- even more than the disgraced Bob Ney-- is fair game, as is his unbelievable taxpayer-funded dining bills-- more than what the next 10 big eaters charge the government combined-- is fair game. But even in light of yesterday's resignation of Mark Foley, Steve won't make an issue out of the widespread knowledge that there's a child predator scandal or two rattling around in English's closet.
Steve knows exactly what he wants to do when he gets to Washington. He has a plan for creating much needed jobs in NW Pennsylvania, revolving around wind power-- a Great Lakes Wind Farm-- and alternative energy. He is eager to get our troops out from "the middle of a civil war of our own making" in Iraq and is gung-ho on helping pass a Murtha-like solution. And he wants to put as much energy as he can into affordable health care.
"On my first day on the job I would be the 73rd congressman to sign on as a co-sponsor to John Conyers' HR-676, American physicians' prescription to solve the health care crisis, which the Republicans have bottled up in committee, since their party is owned by the Insurance Industry, who have, not incidentally, given Phil English hundreds of thousands of dollars."
Steve talks about his idea for making Social Security permanently solvent, just by lifting the earnings cap so that every American, not just the middle class, pays in 6.2% of income. And his solution to our political mess is just as clear-minded:
"We can end corruption in DC by electing people who refuse to take lobbyists money, who refuse to be bought by corporations and who support campaign finance reform based on public funding as in Maine and Arizona... The only way we're going to stop this is if we stop hiring the foxes who keep eating the chickens."
Like almost all the challengers we've met this year, the DCCC isn't paying attention to Steve and he's pushing on without them, running a grassroots campaign-- lots of lawn signs, unions halls, parades, civic clubs, senior citizens homes, colleges...
Steve is a brilliant debater and he cut English to threads in 2004 and English is petrified to take him on one on one this year. There are 3 candidates forums coming up sponsored by non-partisan groups like AARP, CrimeWatch, the Butler County Chamber of Commerce, etc. It looks like Steve will be debating an empty chair (although there is a third party candidate, Tim Hagberg from the Constitution Party, even further to the right than English).
Media is pretty inexpensive in the district and I'm hoping we can help Steve to buy some 30-second cable TV spots in Erie today. The spots cost $26 each. If we can raise $2,600 amongst ourselves he'll have 100 targeted TV spots in the district's main population center.
The Blue America ActBlue Page is open for business. I hope it will encourage you that today I have 20 autographed copies of the brilliant new book by Sidney Blumenthal, How Bush Rules -- Chronicles of a Radical Regime, one of the most important and best-written political books of the entire Bush era.
And as an extra treat, the first 5 people who contribute $250 or more will get a personally inscribed, autographed copy of Steve Porter's latest novel, Hannes Klar, which isn't even out in the U.S. yet. These are editions from the already sold-out first U.K. printing.
Login Here
Share This
Spotlight
Howie!
bonjour!
I know we’re all excited about Foley but let’s try to keep this about the Porter v English race. Besides, if you read the piece yet you’ll notice there are very serious allegations about English being another Republican who has had problems keeping his paws off young boys.
[Previously the AFL-CIO has supported English, although this year they have endorsed Steven]
What the H were they thinking? Well I read your article, Howie, and I’m sold (as usual).
(Also threw in sawbucks for the Blue America PAC and Dr. Wulsin.)
Steve,
From down here in the Shenango Valley, the race doesn’t seem to have gotten much attention yet. There really hasn’t been much about either you or English in The Sharon Herald. (Though the anti-English letters to the editor seem to be more than last time around.) Anything planned to make the Sharon paper? Have the Meadville and Erie media been covering this more?
Welcome, Steve. Thanks so much for joining us here today and for fighting such a good fight in PA.
Amazing how those who have been sold out over prescription drugs, job outsourcing etc. are starting to wake up and see that they’ve been duped by the GOP. I really hope people in your district are awake to this and hand you a victory in November.
An issue close to me is the one brought up here about 767. I’m in the IT industry and the organization I work for is “near shoring” jobs to Mexico as quickly as they can. It’s not really because they or our clients want to, it’s just become the only way we can compete in the current market.
What can be done to correct this? What is the possibility of companies being penalized for sending these jobs out of the country in the future? Can we bring these jobs back home? What will it take?
Hi. I’m Steve Porter, the person running in PA-03 against Republican incumbent Phil English. I just got in from party headquarters in Erie, PA, and will be happy to answer your questions. Thanks for writing.
Steve
Steve, welcome to Firedoglake. We would have been happy to have you join us at any time, but with all this hullabaloo breaking about how Hastert and Boehner have been covering up the Foley mess, it’s even more exciting to have you– especially because of all the rumors about English and his history of molesting young men.
uncle toby @ 6
If you have local papers that aren’t in the “spotlight” list on regional PA media, you can always get an email address, a name and a title and leave them in the comments, we’ll try to make sure Mark Steckyl sees them and ads them to the list.
Also folks can alert other PA media that Steve is joining us here for a chat today. And hit the “Blue America” contribute button, of course.
Greetings Dr. Porter. My question(s) are up at #7. A shorter version would basically be the following: Is “near shoring” just the “way of the future” or is it something controls can be placed on to keep jobs (like mine) in the US? What impact on the issue do you hope to have?
I’m in for one cable spot, Dr. Porter, although I wish it could be more. Howie has shown us an endless parade of GOP incumbents who deserve defeat, but this Jabba person seems particularly worthy of firing.
I’m interested in knowing what issues voters raise when you campaign — what’s motivating voters this year?
Best of luck to you, sir, looking forward to meeting you at the Blue America Swearing-In Celebration in DeeCee in January 2007!
To Uncle Toby:
I have been campaigning in the area for months, but there hasn’t been great coverage. I will have several events in the area soon which I hope will be covered.
I will be having a discussion of health care at the Living Center in Mercer on Oct. 4th, and will be addressing the Grove City Rotary on Oct. 5th. The Mercer Co. Democratic dinner is on Oct. 14th (I will be there), and I will be doing a candidate forum at the Knights of Columbus in Greenville on the 17th. I am scheduled to walk Sharon to meet people on the 21st, and we are trying to set up a debate at the Sharon Penn State Campus on the 24th or 31st. There will be candidate forums on the 25th at Butler Comm. Coll. and on the 26th at Slippery Rock. Additionally, I have sent nearly 50 press releases to all the papers, including the Sharon Herald since my announcement. That said, I cannot compel the media to cover anything. Thanks for asking.
Steve
Dr. Steven Porter @ 13
Which is why it’s so crucial for us to help Steve get his cable spots up on the Erie TBS system today. It’s only $26 a spot and we all should give what we can to help. I did and I know Teddy did. The local papers are owned by Republicans and they’re very much in bed with English and will never do anything that will help Steve unless they are forced to.
welcome to FDL, Mr Porter, and thanks for coming by.
Don’t have anything to ask, just sending good wishes and enough $ thru the act blue page to buy 2 cable spots.
I so want a Congress of smart people who actually care about the people they represent. Good luck and best wishes.
To Zergle–on “near shoring”
My heart goes out to the people of this district. Since my opponent took office–and due largely to his votes–the economy has been devasted by outsourcing. The Dept. of Labor has listed over 9,700 jobs lost due to outsourcing, and Alan Tonelson (who wrote “The Race to the Bottom”) called PA-03 “ground zero” for the exportation of US jobs.
Robert Fogel won the Nobel Prize in economics in 1993, largely for his work demonstrating that there is a moral component to economics which goes beyond policy. The answer to your question is that the morality of Congress has to change from one of supporting the short-term greed of exploiting cheap foreign labor markets to one which tries to globalize the world’s economy not by dropping US workers to third-world levels, but by raising third-world workers (and their environment) to US standards.
That will only happen if Congress is elected without being owned by the special interests who profit from bills like HR 767, which only encourage the outsourcing of jobs.
That is why electing clean legislators is so very important. Beyond that, we can also insist on re-vitalizing our own manufacturing base (particularly in PA-03) with both defense and public works projects.
Sadly, much of our $522 billion defense budget is shipped to overseas contracts. That has to stop, and I would introduce a bill to stop it. Finally, we can create a bonanza of new industry by insisting on building clean, alternative, American-made energies. Ethanol plants, coal gasification, wind power, and solar power are all naturals for Western PA. We need legislators to promote that kind of investment partnership between government and industry instead of feeding Halliburton in Iraq.
I hope that answers you.
Steve
Welcome Dr. Porter!
How has your Great Lakes Wind Farm proposal been received? In some places, it is seen as a radical treehugger idea to be scorned, while in others it is seen as a good idea worth exploring for lots of reasons.
(And a little tech note for our guest: if you click on the “Quote this comment” button underneath someone’s comment, the FDL servers will put that comment in your “reply” box at the bottom. Simply move your cursor to the end of the original quote (after it says “/blockquote”) and type away. It saves all the “To Uncle Toby” typing, and makes it obvious what you are replying to.)
Hi Dr. Porter,
I read the above article, and all I could think about was Bob Roberts, a movie where Gore Vidal plays the very smart, very capable Pennsylvania incumbent and Tim Robbins plays the upstart Republican plotter who wins the election through a series of incredibly dirty tricks. Vidal’s character was an almost uncanny prediction of what happened to Democratic incumbents two years after the movie came out, ie, the 1994 Republican sweep of Congress.
The reason I’m reminded of that is that you’re sticking to issues, and seem to have a great deal of faith in your voters. But I wonder– have references to actual bills ever helped? Do people ever look those up? I mean, it sounds like English has all the character of a well-used toilet brush. Why not go after that? Why attempt such a dry campaign? Why do you have such faith in the Pennsylvania voter, the same type of person who has consistently voted for Santorum?
I lived in Pittsburgh for a number of years as a student at CMU, and I have cousins who live in rural PA. I’ve seen a real disconnect between the native Pennsylvanian and economic reality. My favorite was the purchasing of two stadia in Pittsburgh. The conventional wisdom of the time was, the city and mayor were wondering why they didn’t have a high-tech industry, since they had such a prestigious, world-renowned computer science institute in CMU, or a fantastic theater community, and so forth. So, to draw in the intelligensia (or rather, keep them in town), they decided to build the stadia, thinking that this is what the city needs. More sports, because that’s what every computer scientist and aspiring thesbian wants, and has always wanted. Meanwhile, the recent housing boom has completely passed Pittsburgh by, and as far as I know, graduates continue to leave the city rather than choose to stay.
I realize it’s not the district that you’re trying to compete in, but after reading that above description, I’m not sure it’s so much different. There was a real anti-intellectual and anti-university streak among residents of Pittsburgh to CMU students, and it wasn’t town/college divisions like we saw with the Duke scandal. It was more of a resentment that we weren’t in the community, and even when we were, we were ridiculed. I remember helping rebuild after a series of tornadoes ripped through the city and surrounding areas, and construction workers sneering at us rather than work alongside us.
In short, there was a real communication divide between blue collar and white collar, to simplify the situation drastically. The above description of your campaign is so fact-based, and relies so much on the reader drawing their own inferences, that it’s troubling to me. Are people making those connections, do you think? Are there alternative tactics you can take? Are you trying to win ‘cleanly’, whatever that means, or are you trying to win?
To TeddySanFran.
There are six or seven issues which have surfaces constantly in this campaign. Their order of importance changes with the demographic of the voters or the headlines on any given day. They are: the economy (particularly outsourcing in this district), Bush’s policy in Iraq, health care, Social Security and the attacks on pensions, the Bush energy policy and gas prices, the degradation of our environment, illegal immigration, and the corruption in Washington.
I would think that these are pretty national issues as well. PA-03 is a greying district. The largest single source of income here is retirement, which accounts for 34% of the population. The next largest is “professionals” (doctors, teachers, lawyers, etc.) which accounts for 17%. All else is less. At one time maufacturing was at the top of the list. So in PA-03, job loss and “senior citizen” issues like health care and pensions are usually at the forefront. But I hesitate to add a growing, palpable disgust for the Iraq war and all incumbents in general.
Steve
Dr Porter - It’s wonderful to have you here! I hope we can do a nice bit today to help your campaign - Howie always introduces us to candidates who we would be proud to have speaking for us.
Could you tell us a bit about the issues that your constituents ask about the most?
Peterr @ 17
Many thanks for the help. To your question, the Wind Farm idea, which English scoffed at as “too expensive” in the last race has been quite well-received this time out, no doubt due to soaring gasoline prices. We are going to have to convert to non-fossil fuels and soon. There is more carbon dioxide in our atmosphere than there has been in 600,000 years, and the temperature of the earth is now higher than at any time in the last million years. We are playing with our own extinction in this administration, and the irony is that there is a fortune to be made from clean, re-newable energy sources. As to the objections of environmentalist who use the “not in my backyard” arguement, we can be energy innovative without being environmentally unsound. The alternative is unthinkable.
Steve
Steve,
You mention anti-incumbency (which, of course, is also related to the pay-raise with the state legislators). Does this resonate across the district, or more so in the Dem strongholds of Erie City and Shenango Valley, and less so in the rural swath in-between? If so, focusing on English’s ineffectiveness (and taste for junkets) might be an effective way to attract support in the “red” area of the district.
Hi Dr. Porter,
Much as it shames me to admit it as someone who grew up in Pennsylvania, I’ve never visited the northwest. Is the steel industry gone from there? I grew up in the Lehigh Valley, and they’re turning Bethlehem Steel into a shopping mall.
I like your emphasis on rebuilding the manufacturing base. I’ve been an engineer for twenty-five years, and it’s been increasingly hard to find parts built in the U.S. That can’t be good news either for the economy or our security.
UPDATE: Much of my engineering experience is in the defense industry, which is part of the reason I’m concerned about the security aspects of this issue.
Anyway, my question is: Have there been any polls done for your race? If so, how do they look?
Dr. Steven Porter @
16
One of the things we’re going to be pushing heavily here at FDL if you and your fellow Dems take control of the house is for investigations into war profiteering, and I think people would be really interested to know details like this. Not only are people’s jobs being shipped overseas, but so are their tax dollars, to pay for an unwanted war while our own infrastructure crumbles.
I’d be curious to know what you think the impact of your proposed bill would be.
mmr @ 18
I am trying to win. But there is so much more behind your comment. Let’s start with the allegations on the internet about my opponent. I have no idea whether or not they are true. They are for now merely hearsay–unsubstantiated rumor. It is not for me to investigate them but for the media. It is not for me to try to capitalize upon them because that would be morally wrong and, from a practical point of view, political suicide, for then I could be accused of spreading libel and/or slander. Beyond that, there is a blight on our political landscape–that of obfuscating the issues with personal attacks, slime, and trash. To become a part of that for me is like trying to raise the money for a narcotics rehabilitation center by sell cocaine. Somewhere, sometime, we have to stop this kind of campaigning. The way to do that is with the truth and the issues. If allegations about anyone are true, then it is only right to investigate and bring them to light–but again, that is not the job of the candidate. It is the job of the media. My job is to discuss the issues upon which hang the well-being of the people of this district, our nation, and our world. I hope that makes some sense to you both ethically and politically.
Steve
Siun @ 20
I think I just did that in a previous reply. What I would like to say to you is to thank you and all of the bloggers here today for the warm welcome. There are times when it is very, very lonely on the campaign trail. Today you all have made me feel as if I am not alone. Believe me, that is a great gift to me.
Steve
uncle toby @ 22
It resonates everywhere and is another of the items which shows the disconnect between those who are governed and the ones doing the governing. The anger and lack of trust with incumbents for the lies and self-aggrandizement is everywhere palpable and, for me, a sign that the democracy is in peril.
Steve
Cujo359 @ 23
The steel industry and tool instustries are pretty much gone–shells of their former selves. I have seen no recent polls. The last one that really mattered was the May primary in which English and I virtually split the total vote (49.33% for me and 50.67% for him). This is a winnable race because of the state of both the district and the nation.
Steve
Steve, I know in 2004, the Republicans smeared you with a baseless attack that you were advocating forced sterilizations. John Amato over at Crooks and Liars just sent me a note telling me that a Republican official in South Carolina actually is adocating forced sterilizations– and comparing it to neutering stray dogs. Here’s the quote “What we’ve got is a failure in society, whether it’s in Mount Pleasant with yuppie parents or whether it’s on the East Side with poor crackhead parents. We pick up stray animals and spay them. These mothers need to be spayed if they can’t take care of theirs… Once they have a child and it’s running the streets, to let them continue to have children is totally unacceptable. Deadbeat dads might ought to be sterilized as well.
Jane Hamsher @ 24
As to an investigation, as the saying goes, “from you mouth to God’s ears.” As to how the bill might be received, I think well because it will play to all areas of the nation and to our obvious needs for both homeland security and new energy.
The outsourcing of defense contracts is both economically and militarily insane. I am sure you know that as our own textile industry has melted away, all military uniforms are made in cheap–often “sweat shop”–foreign nations. That the Green Berets should wear berets made in Singapore when the mills of South Carolina go under is insanity to me. But worse is the outsourcing of sensative miliary equipment. The computer chip which goes into the guidance system of a rocket once made in Communist China might well find its way into the rocket of a nation whose missiles are aimed at our heart. In WWII, many was the American soldier shot in the Pacific with bullets stamped “made in the USA” because of similar policies.
I repeat: THERE IS A MORAL COMPONENT TO ECONOMICS, and the sooner we acknowledge it and apply it, the better.
Steve
Dr. Steven Porter @
30
Dr. Porter,
I read a lot here, don’t post much. But this statement really resonates with me. Sent a bit to your campaign–hope it helps.
Howie Klein @ 29
The trash that English put out about my book was unconscionable, and the position you quote above is for me morally intolerable. There is no instance of forces sterization which I would ever support. We have the right to limit our own reproductive systems and that is where the right begins and ends. Both men and women can have medical procedures which render them incapable of reproduction–and the right to do those procedures rests with them and them alone. Even the rapist whose release from prison might endanger a future women through forced impregnation deserves that right. For me, rape is a crime for which I personally would never accept release from jail. And if a state were to have some kind of sterilization as a quid pro quo for release, it would have to be with the absolute acquiescense of the convicted felon. It might be interesting to note that chemical steriliztaion is presently mandatory for a sex offender convicted twice in Florida. That law is repugnant to me–as is releasing the convicted offender.
Steve
I gave to others on Act Blue this AM, but reading about Erie and Steve Porter brought back memories of my Pennsylvania years (at Lehigh in Bethlehem in the 1960s) and I thought I could spring for one more. Wind energy and energy conservation initiatives are excellent ways to reindustrialize the USA.
Mr Porter - regarding wind power in the Great Lakes -
I spend a fair amount of time with family in Ireland. There’s small wind turbine farms being built in many areas there. There are problems with siting that need to dealt with, particulary in regards to the well-being of nearby residents, protecting wildlife and, yes, protecting the greater horizions. Wind turbines are also wind dependent, no wind, no power. But they are part of the greater solution of how we find energy source to power our world without destroying our planet.
From the homes of several family members in Co. Leitrim and Co. Cavan, we can see wind turbines on the hills. It reminds us of all the power we need to sustain our way of life. It is visible - unlike many of the heavily polluting power generation methods like coal fired generating plants used now that are far from most people who use the power. I find myself turning off a few lights, settling under two or three blankets for sleep rather than keeping the heaters on all night in those old stone cottages, when I see those turbines go still as the winds die at sunset.
There’s ongoing pilot projects in the EU about using tidal power as well, but I don’t know if the tidal influences in the Lakes are stong enough to consider pursuing tidal power. There’s going to be a lot of pieces in the energy puzzle. I urge you to check out the energize America pdf that you can find by following the link in the dKos story, if you haven’t done so already.
Dr. Steven Porter @ 25
Dr. Porter,
Thanks for responding to my questions. I do agree with you that there is this blight on our political landscape, but I do wonder if it’s recent or if it’s been an ongoing thing. I’m not enough of a political historian to draw any real conclusions, but I do recall phrasing along the lines that politics is a dirty game played for keeps.
As for casting aspersions that might be libelous, well, that’s an interesting tactic that has proven to be very effective by Republicans time and time again. If you’re playing a game, and you decide arbitrary rules for yourself, you limit your effectiveness by reducing your capabilities arbitrarily. There are many, many fascinating articles on game playing on www.sirlin.net that explore this kind of topic. My point is that you have decided that going after someone for a personal flaw is morally ambiguous and lowers political discourse; I would argue that that person has already brought the discourse to this level in the first place, and therefore is playing a different game than you are, and already holds the upper hand by being an incumbent.
As for the analogy of selling cocaine in order to fund cocaine rehabilitation, I personally believe that that’s exactly what should be done, rather than try to shove the problem under the carpet with a ‘war on drugs’ that just doesn’t work and many police are against (www.leap.cc). There’s a reality in the situation that cannot be ignored for the sake of beautiful theory. Personal attacks work because people have decided that they won’t spend the time necessary to learn issues, and so a politician’s character (or perception of character) is what they will judge upon. There’s also an emotional appeal to those arguments that has a greater impact, bypassing the mind and going straight for the heart.
Instead of:
“On my first day on the job I would be the 73rd congressman to sign on as a co-sponsor to John Conyers’ HR-676, American physicians’ prescription to solve the health care crisis, which the Republicans have bottled up in committee, since their party is owned by the Insurance Industry, who have, not incidentally, given Phil English hundreds of thousands of dollars.”
try something more visceral, with more periods and contractions:
“Phil English has received hundreds of thousands of dollars to keep you from getting the drugs you need to survive. He’s been paid off by companies that don’t want to play fair. I would vote for legislation necessary to give you those drugs, because we shouldn’t let people die or suffer when we don’t have to.”
There’s no references to bills, but it says the same thing, in much more emotionally charged wording. Phrases like ‘play fair’, ‘let people die’, and so forth are devastating attacks, and they are leveled against progressives all the time (usually at the expense of fact).
My point is this: everything you’ve said here, I completely agree with. I understand the way in which you’ve arrived at your positions, and I wholeheartedly think they are the right positions. I just think that we, as a general rule, limit ourselves by not playing hardball politics. We should not rely on the media to make our case; we should instead force the media to pay attention. Your positions are founded in solid policy; now amplify those positions with effective rhetoric.
I do apoligize a bit, because I’m taking out a lot of my frustrations with Democratic electioneering in general on you. It’s not fair of me to have generalized the many failed campaigns before yours to yours. But now given the opportunity to talk with a Democratic candidate directly (and one who’s willing to use the word ‘obfuscate’ and assume I know what that means), I’m hoping my complaints can be somewhat useful to you.
Thanks for reading.
Robert Paehlke @ 33
Many thanks.
Ruby Tuesday @ 34
I have many relatives in Ireland (Limerick, Cork, etc.). I know what you are talking about. A Great Lakes Wind Farm can–especially in Lake Erie which is comparatively shallow–be placed unobtrusively out in the water and still be safe from shipping interference, bird migration, and silk damage from the cables carrying the power to shore. About the wind-dependency, there are studies I have seen that indicate that turbines of a certain height and those over a 200-mile expanse are never without power generation capacity. I have also heard proposals of screens enclosing the turbines and whistles on the turbines to protect bird who fly close.
As to the view of the turbines, I am reminded of the quote that “beauty is in the eye of the beholder.” I know many people who spend tons of money to visit the quaint windmills of Holland. A rose by any other name, so to speak.
Steve
Dr. Porter, has your opponent expressed an opinion on the ongoing occupation of Iraq?
Hi, Steve:
My father-in-law was born in Kane, so in his memory I’m going to send a donation.
He would have supported you, without any doubt, if he were still there.
Thank you for opposing that truly awful incumbent.
Howie - been gobsmacked lately. Am in the process of sending you a packet via US mail this week. Hope it will make sense - and I’ll ask someone named “Lynn” to contact you, as every time I start to catch my breath, I get sucked into some new urgent crisis. Lynn is better at coordinating and follow up than I am these days =8-0
I will send this link to some folks that I know at my local electric utility, who have fought quite a battle to get my region off the hook for Enron bills. No guarantees they’ll donate, but I’m sure it wouldn’t hurt.
Thx for all you do, and Steve I wish you all the best. This nation needs you.
Howie, if I ever finish a little animation titled “Dieboldman and the House of Flying ActBlues,” you’ll be the first to know. Working on it has been a real sanity aide, but have only been able to do bits and pieces ;-)
Dear Sir - thanks for running. We have so many great candidates, and Howie is doing yeoman’s work hightlighting many of them.
Just donated.
Is the Senate race affecting your race? How are Murtha and the Veteren and War issues affecting your race?
readerOfTeaLeaves @ 39
I can’t wait!!! Now you have me all excited
Well.. thx, now I just have to finish up the last thing so I can ‘play’ with Flying ActBlues. Too bad I can’t swipe the music from “House of Flying Daggers.”
Dunno if it will help, but I honestly don’t see how many of the DNC ‘messages’ are going to do any good. Those dunces don’t watch nearly enough Chinese movies 8-(((
I wouldn’t want to see turbines on the edge of the Grand Canyon, but I do agree that they can have kinetic beauty like something in a high-brow arts installation. To a great extent, it’s a ’sacrifice’ we must make, how we do it is what we need to work out.
Ultra-high turbines, over-the-horizon farms will not only create cleaner energy, but they will create a lot of great jobs for Americans, in construction and because you can’t out-source completely the day to day power plant operations, cabling and other maintenance that needs to be run.
Thanks, Steve, I think you’d be an excellent representative for your district and our nation. Good luck, and in lieu of buying you a Guinness in honor of shared Irish/New York heritage, I’m off to donate another two cable spots for your campaign.
Good luck!
On the subject of injecting morality into economics, sort of, I ran across this article. Seems you can predict successful store locations using atomic physics:
The analysis reveals promising locations throughout the city for each of the 55 different kinds of stores Jensen studied. Values might for instance prove high for a jewelry store in a particular location if there are other accessory stores nearby selling shoes or hats, but few neighboring grocery or hardware stores.
So, trying to incorporate morality into economic analyses doesn’t sound quite so whacky, does it?
I’m coming into the discussion late, and haven’t had time to read all the comments. I apologize for that. But what I want to know is whether Steve has addressed how he would have voted on the Bush Torture Bill that was passed by the House (and Senate) this week.
ifthethunderdontgetya @ 37
English has been a lock step supporter of Bush’s conduct of the war. Even more, in addition to voting in virtually every instance for Bush’s agenda, he has consistently voted against any investigation into the war–be it of misappropriated funds or the falsification of intelligence reports. He has no plan to end this insanity beyond the “stay the course” madness of the administration.
My own position was from the start that it was lunacy to invade Iraq. And now that we have fomented a civil war and invited the terrorists to join in, our troops are in an intolerable position. We need to re-deploy to a safe perimeter where our soldiers are out of harm’s way but near enough to combat regional terrorism if it escalates out of hand. We need the Iraqi’s to take control of their own defenses and to solve their own internal insurgency. I rather think that the ultimate solution will be some kind of multi-state one where Kurds, Sunnis, and Shiites have sovereign territory with Baghdad a divided city something on the order of Berlin during the Cold War, and where Iraqi oil revenues are shared between the nations thus composed.
Finally, we need to look at the tides of history which this administration has absolutely ignored. We have linked ourselves with a nearly one-thousand-year age of colonial imperialism in which the nations of the developing world were dominated and exploited by the nations of Europe.
There is a great book about the history of the modern world by R.R. Palmer and Joel Colton of Princeton and Duke. They wrote that after WWII, the nations which had dominated the world now had to learn to negotiate with it. What a profound insight–and one totally lacking in Washington today.
One can trace just about all of the turmoil of the Post-WWII world to the failure of the west to do this. South Africa, the loss of the British Empire, the Indo Chinese War and its stepchild in Vietnam, Casto’s overthrow of Batista, and the present crisis in the Middle East are all microcosmic examples of the macrocosmic principle of Palmer and Colton.
To end anti-American terrorism, we will need to do much more than shoot our weapons. We will need to understand the legacy of hate and despair left by the millenium of colonial imperialism and with the other wealthy nations of the world, work to build an economy and social structure in the swamps which produce terrorists which give the people there a chance of a better life.
That is why our leadership in helping to create a two-state solution to the Israeli/Palestinian conflict is so vitally important. As it is, Bush has only encouraged the Islamic nations to turn to more and more radical leaders. That is why it is no surprise that the Iraqi war has been accompanied by the rise of Hamas in Palestine, the growth of Hezbollah in Lebanon, the election of Ahmadinajad in Iran, and the 300% increase in global terrorism.
God help us if people like Bush and English continue in power.
Steve
. . . and your little dog, too @ 38
Many thanks.
Dr. Steven Porter @
30
This is a very important point and I hope we can make people understand it — somebody is benefitting from the status quo and it is neither the American people nor national security. Thanks so much for highlighting Steve, I really hope you can get a chance to fight to right this in Congress. It’s conversation we really need to have.
Flamethrower @ 40
I want to thank Howie, as well, for this opportunity to talk to you all.
The senate race as well as the governor’s race has greatly energized the Democratic base, and that can only help me.
Murtha is well-respected here, and so the Republican attacks on him do not play well for my opponent.
Steve
Ruby Tuesday @ 43
Many thanks.
Steve, it’s great you’re able to join us today. PA-03 needs, and deserves, a representative with your integrity.
My grandfather taught at Grove City for many years. In his memory, you can add a couple more spots to your media buy.
Howie, as always…thanks for all your efforts.
Steve:
Dr. Steven Porter @ 25
I agree with what you say above, and taking all that in consideration, there is no reason your campaign materials can’t say something like, “Erie deserves a Congressman with the character to represent real Pennsylvania values in Washington.”
And you can sprinkle the word “character” throughout your speeches and interviews. Just emphasize your own, and leave English out of it.
This is how Bush beat Gore in 2000. He said he’d bring honor back to the Oval Office. He didn’t talk about blue dresses or hotel rooms in Little Rock. He just talked about “honor” and “character”.
You have a sterling character. Run on it!
Okay, I just kicked in $100 for Steve’s campaign (and $5 for ActBlue), I want to hear about what he has to say in Congress.
Anybody want to match me?
RBG @ 51
Many thanks to you and all the donors to my campaign.
. . . and your little dog, too @ 52
Thank you. My literature does speak of ending the culture of corruption in DC. I hope the electorate is listening.
Steve
neurophius @ 45
Steve is very, very precise in his answers and he may take some time before he gets to your question, although I notice he is getting to all the questions. I’ll throw in my 2 cents, though. He’s one of the least tolerant of the Bush Regime’s trampling of the Constitution I’ve ever come across. Although he has the demeanor of a mild-mannered professor, the guy in a tiger when it comes to protecting the American people. I can’t wait to hear his response.
Dr. Porter @ 46, thank you for such a well written response. I hope we can spotlight (that’s a function where we forward this post) to the newpapers in your district.
Jane Hamsher @ 1:00 pm (#52)
If three more people gave what I did, we will have matched you collectively ;)
Jane Hamsher @ 53
I don’t know what to say beyond thank you. I have often been accused of wearing my heart on my sleeve, and I know that sometimes it is not becoming. But for so many of you to believe in my mission for better government and a better world is just a little overwhelming for me today.
Steve
Howie Klein @ 54
On a related note, I noticed that Sherrod Brown is no longer on the Blue America page. Is that due to his vote on the Torture Bill?
Jane Hamsher @ 53
Well Jane, I already contributed earlier. But since Dr. Porter is so inspiring (and I got paid yesterday), I’ll match you now.
Dr. Steven Porter @ 59
Hi Steve,
I like people who wear their hearts on their sleeves! I just donated for another cable spot.
Best of luck - we’re behind you.
Kathie
Cujo359 @ 60
Yes, I certainly hope he wins and becomes the great Democratic leader I thought he would be. But we don’t feel good about raising money for someone who would vote for the Bush Torture Bill. No one is perfect, but this one made a lot of us ill. Let’s stay on topic though.
It’s $26 to buy Steven a TV spot on Erie TBS cable. I’m hoping we can buy him 100 spots. So anyone who’s feeling a little flush and patriotic today… you can give $26 or $52 bucks or… heck, match Jane’s generous contribution (#53).
Ding! You got a commercial spot!
Steve, I know your webmaster was trying to get the cable spots up on your website so we can see what we’re putting out money in for. Obviously we can check tomorrow or the next day, but do you have any idea if he’ll have the spots up soon?
For my grandmother, who worked at Cooper-Bessemer for years and would be disgusted by the antics of the current administration …here’s a couple more spots for Steve.
OK, Hamsher…you’re $4 short.
May I respectfully argue with you about this?
I live in rural Texas, and rural people know that “Culture of Corruption” is just another Washington slogan. They won’t even hear that.
But Frank Luntz taught Republicans to use words that have impact and meaning for regular people and it has worked in spades for them.
When Bush mentions “victory” 19 times in a speech, there’s a reason for that. When he say’s “9/11″ or “terra” 26 times in a speech, he has good reason to.
The busy and jaded citizen is only going to hear what is repeated, and what is repeated had better be good for the candidate, if not bad for his opponent.
Please just try adding “character” to your usual comments and see if it helps. It sure can’t hurt.
I hope I haven’t overstepped the bounds here, but I feel so passionately that it is words that have defeated Democrats so often, that I can’t remain quiet about it. After all, how often do I have the ear of a real candidate!
In a campaign, the words you use are everything.
Submitted with support for you and respect.
Howie Klein @ 56